Player Stats

Do the stats on players even make a difference cause I think almost every single game for the past 3 weeks I’ve had a team full of the worst bronze, silver and gold players most have under 70 on everything and yet they outplay almost all of my players.                                                                  
And I’m not just on about they can get past me with the ball they can outpace basically all my players despite the insane pace gap, I have Elanga who’s 92 pace, Barnes who’s 90, Frimpong 94 and Young 93 and yet not 1 of them could outrun a bronze CB with between 50-60 pace. Not even just the pace it’s everything, not one of my players can dribble when the player is close they just seem to stand there in fear or something but as soon as I go to my half and kick it about I can dribble perfectly fine without any stops but then as soon as they come near it just freezes up again.                                                      None of my players have any physical whatsoever so pretty much those bronze players with under 70 physical can just push and grab like he’s Khabib and then any of my 89+ physicals push like toddlers. 
The goalkeeping is no better either what could quite possibly be the easiest save of a century looks like the most difficult thing every to my goalkeeper and I’m using Allison and I used to use a 87 Winter wild Rulli who had 99 diving and 90 reflex and yet he wouldn’t see a boulder coming dead at him he was terrible.                         Anyways been fun would just like to know how much ea are ripping off people who spend fortunes on this.