Bounties not paying out when completed correctly.

I just had a last strike bounty in division 6 which states "Score the last goal in your next match and earn a Item Pick". I was 5-3 up (Scored after being 4-3 up) and then scored another to go 6-3. The game ended thereafter. I was then met with a big red X next to the bounty and I did not get my pick despite completing the bounty correctly. 

Anyone else experiencing the same?