PS5 controller not working in online modes

Ps5 controller worked fine on pc yesterday (18.9.trial) on both offline and rush. Today I played some offline games with no problems, but can't play any online modes anymore with the controller. The icons on my players switch to orange and I can't control them at all.

I bought the EA Play Pro for eafc and bf6, off to a great start. Some kind of compensation wouldn't hurt since a subscription of 120 euros isn't exactly cheap. 

Hit me up with any fixes!