Spoiler: Krogan Scouts or Raeka? Why?
And as followup, how did you resolve the choice with Sarissa? I wonder if people feel differently based on the order they made these choices or made them completely separate things. I also just like ...
Forum Discussion
Between Raeka and the Krogren? I don't think ME:A presented that decision very well to begin with. There are plenty of reasons to rescue Raeka. She's already, in the span of about 40 minutes, proved to be a vitally useful ally and a good leader (something the initiative is sorely lacking). But why should I rescue the Krogen? Because they're Krogen and I should feel sorry for them...for being Krogen? I'm sorry but assuming that the Krogen deserve to be saved more than the Salarians is straight up species-ist. I know nothing about the Krogen scouts. I don't know if they're useful or deserve mercy for some specific reason. In fact, choosing to save the Salarians, I would argue, is the objectively smarter decision n terms of hindering the Kett. By the time we get to the flagship they've already started corrupting Krogen biology, let's not give them too much of a head start on Salarians. Like I said the game simply didn't present the decisions well enough to make me feel like saving the Krogen scouts was at all a worth while choice.
Now between Sarissa and Vederia? Power is great and all but Sarissa proved that she can't be trusted. I fully agree with the decision she made and her reasons for making it, but that's not the problem.
She lied about it.
A lie of omission is still a lie. One of the most important aspects of a good leader is the willingness to commit to your decisions and stand by them even in the face of scrutiny and disagreement. Had she done this I would have sided with her wholeheartedly, some times the best decisions are the hardest ones to make, but instead she took the cowards route. Her decision may have been very beneficial to us but we're not choosing whether or not she gets a pat on the head, we're deciding whether or not she's worthy of one of the highest and most powerful leadership positions held by anyone in the initiative.
I promise you, putting your faith in a liar will come back to bite you.
Vederia, despite her inexperience, showed great courage in the face of adversity and a willingness to try and make the situation better for everyone involved. Who did we find out in the dangerous part of the ship trying to get systems back up and running? Certainly not our powerful pathfinder Sarissa, but an inexperienced rookie. Sarissa only showed up after all the real fighting had ended to show off her biotics. Theoretically a bioticly inclined Ryder or other sqaudmate could have jumped in and done the same thing.
I guess it depends on how you look at erm Kettification.
In game being turned into a Kett is a big thing and considered a fate worse than death.
So would you save a bunch of Krogan scouts that are about to suffer that fate and let Raeka die a hero's death?
Or do you save Raeka and let the Krogan suffer a fate worse than death?
I agree it wasn't that well presented particularly on a first playthrough but that's the moral choice behind it.
Your binary choice ignores the innocent civilian Salarians.
@arthurh3535 wrote:Your binary choice ignores the innocent civilian Salarians.
Innocent Salarians....good one 😇
Still, considering the limited number of Krogan that were allowed to come along and me saving the Salarian ark with thousands of them on board, I think the scouts are the fairest choice just the same.
And the moral choice between letting people die or be kettified is still an interesting choice regardless of who is innocent or not, because in the end they all are innocent and didn't deserve to die, so that really is not a determining factor here.
- Random civilian salarians that did not sign up to be put in a dangerous situation vs krogan scouts that knew they were scouting a dangerous alien race.
It makes a small difference. Basically soldier vs. civilian.
Featured Places
