it's a sad truth that exclusive licensing has killed indie development for sports video games. sure, some games exist out there. but anyone trying to make a real competitor to EA's games runs into the same wall: fans want to play with their favorite teams/players.
NOW, i would argue that every person who plays Chel/EASHL will tell you they don't care at all about having a quality online experience WITH irl NHL players.
if someone made a quality competitor to EA's NHL i do believe that the EASHL crowd might hop on. We don't care about HUT. we don't need any of that, we just want a quality online competitive game, built and designed around that experience.
another sad truth: EA is focused on making money (they are a business) and as such, they will do everything they can to make as much money as possible to justify their jobs. not the actual gameplay experience, but money. that's it.
i agree tho, i do wish we could opensource/crowdsource a NEW hockey game. i would play it!