"evoluza;c-1878135" wrote:
"Hortus;c-1878133" wrote:
"Nauros;c-1878120" wrote:
It's not like 80M is some steep requirement, our casual (but old) guild has almost double that.
Your are missing the point. Of course those guilds who already met requirements won't be hurt. But those who don't - will be, and badly. For example, my current guild will need to recruit almost 20 people with average GP higher than our current average. It's just impossible because there is no point for such people to join us - we are complete strangers to them AND we can't do actual PvE content. Even the fact that we are extremely successful for our size (won all our TW, started to clear heroic raids faster than other guilds of our size and age, etc) will change nothing - now we just cut off from the future game.
YOU miss the point of this requirements completey!
As I say above, no 80mil GP, means probably no star and no rewards.
You want that for lower guild's?
Not capping and low guild's miss on any rewards, because they can't achieve One star... Please stop that nonsense
So when 1/4 of their guild quits they lose out on hoth rewards too. Double whammy. Its kind of not nonsense for 65-75 mil gp guilds.
They never could have gotten GTB rewards but will now lose a bunch of hoth rewards..... thats a valid claim.
Cap prevents whining but creates a whole new actual problem that creates more whining.
Honestly IMO CG would have been better off dealing with the whining that a guild chose GTB (bad decision on their part) and lost out on hoth rewards. Its much better than dealing with guild killing that takes away those hoth rewards as well.
Guild makes dumb decision to try GTB and regrets it you can deal with
Company policy that hurts guilds and ends up leaving them with less hoth rewards due to guild destruction is much worse.
Real question is does this effect enough guilds to cause an actual problem.... that I cant say. I do doubut CG would care about 50-100 guilds being destroyed..... now if it was a few thousand.....
Truth be told HSTR destroyed 60-80% of our guild but worked hard to bring in the people leaving other destroyed guilds now we are top 200 TW guild smoking everything.
Best suggestions anyone can make is if you have a tight group of people keep em together and find a merge work at it..... who cares if guild name changes or you dont get to be an officer for 5 months yu will still have your friends and end up in a MUCH better situation
Capital Games Team
