Forum Discussion

Trajector's avatar
Trajector
7 years ago

Chimaera Power Misleading

1. Look at the stats of my Chimaera (ally code 529-789-915), and at those of Ethan Geilvta 2 (same fleet arena server, Darksaber Legacy guild).
Here is the comparison:
Stat: My Chimaera compared to Ethan's

Reinforcement slots: 3 == 3
Abilities: all maxed == all maxed
Speed: 142 < 145
Critical Damage: 150% == 150%
Potency: 33.81% < 36.08%
Special Damage: 21172 < 22352
Special Critical Chance: 10% == 10%
Resistance Penetration: 0 == 0
Special Accuracy: 0% == 0%

2. Now look at the power of both ships.
Power: 41431 > 39571

My power is 1860 greater than the other's power, despite no single stat, none, zilch better than a lower power ship. This is truly astonishing.

It would be much better to change ship power calculation is such a way, that higher power guarantees at least a single stat being better.
  • hendy_2012's avatar
    hendy_2012
    7 years ago
    "Trajector;c-1558740" wrote:
    "Darthpedro;c-1558593" wrote:
    ...
    If that's the case and you don't want help then fine, stop posting to this thread and it will eventually fall out of everyone's view and you won't get any help that you don't want.
    What exactly made you believe I wanted help, rather than opinions?


    Well your title stating that something is wrong when more than likely it isn't wrong and there is an explanation that you may not understand. Which is an opinion by the way.

    Call me a glutton for punishment but I have a compulsion to try to help people who don't understand things.

  • Trajector's avatar
    Trajector
    7 years ago
    "Darthpedro;c-1558766" wrote:
    Well your title stating that something is wrong when more than likely it isn't wrong and there is an explanation that you may not understand. ...
    You are mistaken with your probability analysis, and your less likely scenario is what actually happened.

    Yes I do need help here, but you have not been helpful, as you have been helping me with how it is calculated, and giving me feedback an opinions on topics I am not interested in.

    If you want to help - try to look at everything, not just the title, i.e. look at the section where this post is located, i.e. "Feedback" (not "General" as you seem to have assumed), and also at the actual post, "It would be much better to change ship power calculation" for instance. Taking everything together, you will see how you can help, i.e. by expressing an opinion about the calculation.
  • hendy_2012's avatar
    hendy_2012
    7 years ago
    As far as I have seen there is nothing wrong with the stat calculation and, as you have only given less than half of the information, there is no reason to change my opinion which I am giving you as feedback . With all of the information it may be possible to explain why what you are seeing as a problem is not actually a problem.

    Changing something because you don't understand it or want to understand it is not the right answer.

    BTW it's hard to "look at everything" as you say, when a good chunk of the information isn't there.
  • Trajector's avatar
    Trajector
    7 years ago
    "ChristophIV;c-1558897" wrote:
    May I suggest you add "what are people's thoughts on..." to your initial post, and change the title from "Chimaera's power wrong" (because it isn't according to the current formulas) to something like "Ship GP is misleading".
    Finally a single helpful suggestion. Hopefully the discussion can now get back on track on how to persuade CG to make it better.
  • Nihion's avatar
    Nihion
    7 years ago
    "Trajector;c-1559026" wrote:
    "ChristophIV;c-1558897" wrote:
    May I suggest you add "what are people's thoughts on..." to your initial post, and change the title from "Chimaera's power wrong" (because it isn't according to the current formulas) to something like "Ship GP is misleading".
    Finally a single helpful suggestion. Hopefully the discussion can now get back on track on how to persuade CG to make it better.


    Dude. I look at all your posts here, and it sure doesn’t sound like you want help. I’ll bet it has everything to do with you’re Thrawn, yet you’ve attacked everyone that commented about it. You won’t accept other people’s opinions here, you’re just trying to prove that it’s wrong. Why? Just accept it
  • Trajector's avatar
    Trajector
    7 years ago
    "Why?" Because I want to make the game better. Specifically, I want players looking at the power of 2 ships being able to establish that a ship with more power will have at least a single combat stat better.
  • kieronkumar's avatar
    kieronkumar
    7 years ago
    I agree - GP seems to be largely an irrelevant number at the moment, both for ships and for characters. Star count makes a large difference in GP for a relatively smaller effect on actuall usefulness (cf gear levels).
  • hendy_2012's avatar
    hendy_2012
    7 years ago
    "FailingCrab;c-1559877" wrote:
    I agree - GP seems to be largely an irrelevant number at the moment, both for ships and for characters. Star count makes a large difference in GP for a relatively smaller effect on actuall usefulness (cf gear levels).


    To be fair this isn't new. Power rating has never been an overly useful stat not before the move from power to GP and not after. A big part of that problem in characters is that the actual effect mods have on stats really isn't weighted at all nor are set bonuses or synergy combos.
  • Trajector's avatar
    Trajector
    7 years ago
    With ground units it is indeed much more complicated due to mods, so worth taking the simplest case, which is ships, and improving it first.

About SWGOH General Discussion

Discuss and share your feedback on Star Wars: Galaxy of Heroes with fellow players.

77,697 PostsLatest Activity: 2 days ago