So just to be clear. Now, the following apply:
1. only the people in the guild at start of raid can collect
2. if those same people get below 50 they cannot collect
3. one person cannot collect more than the maximum normally allowed in a week
It seems pretty clear that only number 3 was required to be equitable here (and it already was in place), so it does seem like only certain people's complaints are listened to (especially given the volume of complaints). This is literally the least important problem that could have been addressed here and it only exacerbates the very real very terrible problems with this raid
I do however agree that taking advantage of an exploit to refresh your roster is cheating (b/c same person is getting to go multiple times in one raid), but that seems like a completely separate issue (that shouldn't even be possible in the first place)
Is anyone looking into the problem that caused people to combine guilds like this? I believe there are a few hundred threads discussing how awful the tuning was difficulty (and tedium)-wise
