Executor is a beast? [MERGE]

https://youtu.be/xLkGD4Us9Zw
$200 invested in what was billed by developers as top of meta and nearly unbeatable at 7* and it is losing to leftovers. Refund or rework

Shhhhh omg don’t cause more nerf please delete your post

So far I've heard of
- Male
- Nego
- Rebels
- Finalizer
beating various Executor fleets (different stars and lineups).

Gonna have to see if there's a super secret OP lineup that CG tested and wished us all "good luck" for but I don't see anything else than HT, RC and either XB, IG or S1 to be ideal.
And if the HT, RC, XB/IG/S1 lineup is alrdy the supposed best lineup and it getting beaten so easily by above fleets is WAI then that's a 10/10 joke and many ppl just wasted resources worth a 1/2 GL, bloated their roster and can very possibly enjoy facing opponents with a GL more now.

Scimitar is an interesting choice for that lineup. Are we sure there is not a better lineup that could work?

"SkiTrooper;d-248113" wrote:
https://youtu.be/xLkGD4Us9Zw
$200 invested in what was billed by developers as top of meta and nearly unbeatable at 7* and it is losing to leftovers. Refund or rework

The ship has been out in the wild for just a few hours - I think it's too early to draw conclusions. If it's not performing as intended CG will either buff it, nerf other ships or release another ship that makes it super OP.

"Kyno;c-2287065" wrote:
Scimitar is an interesting choice for that lineup. Are we sure there is not a better lineup that could work?

Certainly less than ideal. This is just the worst fleet I've seen beating it. There are videos of home1 and malevolence beating more optimal lineups

"SkiTrooper;c-2287070" wrote:

"Kyno;c-2287065" wrote:
Scimitar is an interesting choice for that lineup. Are we sure there is not a better lineup that could work?

Certainly less than ideal. This is just the worst fleet I've seen beating it. There are videos of home1 and malevolence beating more optimal lineups

Yeah, I have seen. It's a little early, and this being a bad example, just makes it a little bold to call for a rework already.

It's entirely possible that it's an offensive powerhouse and easily beatable on defense. Like SEE, the FO fleet, Imperial Troopers, etc.

If that's the case I'd be ecstatic and give CG a hesitant thumbs up. People were super worried about never being able to beat it, so if they can beat it with various different fleets, that could be a good thing. A lot of people hate fleets, so if there is a way to easily win on offense, but that same way doesn't just crush people on defense, I'd call it a win-win. But, it is still early, we'll have to wait and see.

Cough cough HAHAHAHAHA

"WD_40;c-2287081" wrote:
It's entirely possible that it's an offensive powerhouse and easily beatable on defense. Like SEE, the FO fleet, Imperial Troopers, etc.

If that's the case I'd be ecstatic and give CG a hesitant thumbs up. People were super worried about never being able to beat it, so if they can beat it with various different fleets, that could be a good thing. A lot of people hate fleets, so if there is a way to easily win on offense, but that same way doesn't just crush people on defense, I'd call it a win-win. But, it is still early, we'll have to wait and see.

Hard disagree, at this cost I want something that is only reliably beat in a mirror. I already can beat everything with Mal.