Guild participation

Our guild always sits around 31/50 to 33/50. Can’t seem to fill with players willing to follow a couple of simple rules

Ya, gotta agree with OP. We've had this same issue in our guild lately. Not sure what it is, but people just aren't participating in the events much anymore. They'll log in daily, but they either don't know to join or miss the events. Kinda sucks.

We've had a lot of people leave after the whole Malak thing. I think people are getting fed up with the game. 10 people have left. 3 let us know in Discord and the other 7 just stopped playing. We just started consistently clearing heroic sith raid too. I guess not even traya shards could get people to stick around.

CG is killing this game.

I’ve found that the key to guild contentment is finding players with the same level of commitment/activity. Otherwise, you’ll continually be frustrated.
Staying in an underperforming guild seriously handicaps your own growth. You have to choose what’s important to you.

If you aren’t a HSR guild, you will struggle to attract recruits - everyone, even Level 80 players want to do HSR (even if they aren’t ready).

HSR fractured my original guild, causing conflicts between the active, ready to go-for-Traya players and the more casual players. The actives left and went through a couple of mergers before we met the similarly minded folks who have made the current guild the best I’ve been in with either of my accounts.

It’s the people and matching expectations that breeds happiness.

We've had a similar thing. We merged two guilds to make a HSTR guild and during that time our participation, tickets and TW performance were great. Then stuff happened and most of the merged players left to rejoin their original guild. We're still clearing HSTR with 38 members or so, but it's been demoralising to see the drop in TB rewards and raid tickets.

"Hell8MySoul;c-1847031" wrote:

You’ve been in the same guild for 3 years and only just starting to do heroic tank... if your a active player I’d highly recommend joining another guild as most have been doing heroic tank for ages and at least half been farming heroic sith

extremely active player, and believe me im painfully aware of how far behind we are as a group. but i've never been one for jumping about in any game ive ever been a part of. you are quite right though, I do understand bro. If our group ever completely falls apart i intend to do just that, but as is...happy enough here... just cant help but wish we had more active players.

as far as heroic tank...i can almost solo it...so it was kinda inevitable we'd get through it eventually... buts its crazy how fine a line that was for so long :) thanks for the advice bud, do totally understand.

I have seen lots of large Whales/Krakens leave the game recently as well. You have to ping people on discord to join and use all your resources and medias to recruit people.

"DaarthBrewer;c-1847029" wrote:
We aggressively kicked, over the course of 4 months, at least 25 people. We now are full and seeing more stars in TB, some wins in TW, and everyone active daily. Just make sure you get to 50 before kicking. Make a list and boot one or two upon getting full. State rules clearly. Have an absence channel.

@DaarthBrewer Where are you recruiting people? I have never seen that many people looking at one time ?

"FailingCrab;c-1847182" wrote:
We've had a similar thing. We merged two guilds to make a HSTR guild and during that time our participation, tickets and TW performance were great. Then stuff happened and most of the merged players left to rejoin their original guild. We're still clearing HSTR with 38 members or so, but it's been demoralising to see the drop in TB rewards and raid tickets.

Maybe it's time to think about another merger. It sucks, but just not enough active players for as many guilds there are.

"Unknownhost;c-1847184" wrote:

"Hell8MySoul;c-1847031" wrote:

You’ve been in the same guild for 3 years and only just starting to do heroic tank... if your a active player I’d highly recommend joining another guild as most have been doing heroic tank for ages and at least half been farming heroic sith

extremely active player, and believe me im painfully aware of how far behind we are as a group. but i've never been one for jumping about in any game ive ever been a part of. you are quite right though, I do understand bro. If our group ever completely falls apart i intend to do just that, but as is...happy enough here... just cant help but wish we had more active players.

as far as heroic tank...i can almost solo it...so it was kinda inevitable we'd get through it eventually... buts its crazy how fine a line that was for so long :) thanks for the advice bud, do totally understand.

Commitment to the same guild all that time is an admirable quality don’t get me wrong, but you should have a think if being loyal to the guild you’ve always been in out-ways the benefit of being in a more active guild. Whatever suits your game play style at the end of the day but I’d imagine you want treya at least some point sooner rather than by the time another raid comes out?

"Monel;c-1847189" wrote:

"FailingCrab;c-1847182" wrote:
We've had a similar thing. We merged two guilds to make a HSTR guild and during that time our participation, tickets and TW performance were great. Then stuff happened and most of the merged players left to rejoin their original guild. We're still clearing HSTR with 38 members or so, but it's been demoralising to see the drop in TB rewards and raid tickets.

Maybe it's time to think about another merger. It sucks, but just not enough active players for as many guilds there are.

I think a merger is called for, but unfortunately everyone else wanting a merger is also a 40ish person guild looking for 10-15 people.