Holdo maneuver
Having it is a guaranteed clear of fleet zones in GAC. As long as you don't need the banners from doing it first try you just nuke the enemy capital ship and clean up with trash on second. Fleet in GA...
Forum Discussion
"EventineElessedil;c-2062857" wrote:"Ephran;c-2062444" wrote:"Slothmaster;c-2061907" wrote:
Also I know this thread isn’t about the movie but god the Holdo Maneuver is so bad for the internal logic of the series.
Who knew we could have just lobbed kamikaze pilots into the Death Star until it blew up? Better yet, get droids to pilot the ships.
Lol they confirmed that the only reason it worked was that the Raddus had a reinforced shield. Without that shield it would have disintegrated on contact with the enemy shield and wouldn't have done anything. Who knew it doesn't do anything to the logic of the series, especially when that logic is based on the rule of cool.
One of the standard Star Wars physics truths we have accepted is that bigger ships have stronger shields, presumably because they have room for bigger generators. It's a simple explanation that we can all understand, strength scales with size. It stands to reason that Supremacy should have had stronger shields than Raddus.
Now you want us to accept that Raddus had a "reinforced" shield? Really? That's the explanation we are given? What exactly is so special about a "reinforced" shield? Does it have rebar in it? Probably not, maybe just MOAR BETTER shield generators than the other ships, with extra special deflecting power. Power to deflect the strongest bombardment, and fly through other ships' shields with impunity.
Hey, wait a minute now ... the Raddus had more better shields like this, and the only strategy they could come up with was to run away? Why not take their impervious shields, turn around, and just frontal assault the enemy fleet, fly through their shields at point-blank range and blow them into smithereens?
I suppose it's a good thing that Supremacy didn't have EXTRA MOAR BETTER shields or the whole maneuver would have been like running into a brick wall.
They should put these "reinforced" shields on every ship. Boy, that would show them who's boss!
On an unrelated side note: it was called a "Star Destroyer" not because it was a destroyer of stars, but because it is a destroyer (a class of naval ship) that flies among the stars. Frigates, destroyers, cruisers, freighters ... all of these SHIPS belong to the NAVY that commands them.
I just had to get that off my chest. I'm so relieved.
If you had actually watched the movie you would also have noticed that the hole in the Supremacy's shield that Finn and Rose sliced through was *EXACTLY* where Holdo hit it. If you're too far up your own backside to accept the fact that the size of the ship is unrelated (the first Death Star didn't even seem to have a shield you utter maroon) at the very least pay enough to attention to the movie to pick up on subtle clues like that.
Edit: also reinforced doesn't mean impervious and why do you think they were running out of fuel? They were being bombarded and their shields were using their fuel up. Good grief, use basic logic, it's really not that hard.
