Kenobi - S1E3 (Spoilers)

"MasterSeedy;c-2364213" wrote:

Help kenobi get away from what? Since there is no Vader in your story.

Vader who never appears on screen with Kenobi at the same spot in the same time. The Grand Inquisitor. Other Inquisitors. A grandmother with a broom, frankly, given how pathetic Kenobi is right now.

You want to make the show as interesting as possible since it’s only 6 episodes.

Yes, exactly. And since Kenobi is no match for Vader, there's nothing interesting about them fighting. There was not one moment of dramatic tension in the fight between Vader & Kenobi, not one split second where you thought, 'Okay, here is where Kenobi turns it around and wins this duel.'

Again, losing a fight vs. Vader isn't interesting, because almost anyone would lose a fight vs. Vader. Kenobi at his absolute best barely won against Vader.

Vader fighting someone? Oh, no! Don't tell me who wins! I'm sure it's a very close contest!

Yawn.

Vader getting reports back from the Inquisitors as a looming menace who might show up on the planet before Kenobi gets away is useful. Vader actually fighting Kenobi? Not useful or interesting at all.

Do you seriously expect me to believe you thought Kenobi might win that fight?

You got to face your demons to move forward.

Which requires Vader to be physically present? No, not in the least. And again as I already said, the MOST Vader gives you is a chance to be done with the past. There is nothing in confronting Vader that gives Kenobi motivation or hope for the future. His "demons" are something to fight against, but not something to fight FOR.

According to your logic, Vader is required for Kenobi to move forward, therefore if Vader had died on Mustafar but the Emperor survived, Kenobi would never recover because his "demon" was no longer possible to confront.

It's just not true. It doesn't make any sense. The "demon" is inside Kenobi. Vader could have been made into a fun, looming threat, never quite materializing, but as a physical antagonist Vader is worse than someone that Kenobi has more hope of actually beating.

"MasterSeedy;c-2364213" wrote:

Help kenobi get away from what? Since there is no Vader in your story.

Vader who never appears on screen with Kenobi at the same spot in the same time. The Grand Inquisitor. Other Inquisitors. A grandmother with a broom, frankly, given how pathetic Kenobi is right now.

You want to make the show as interesting as possible since it’s only 6 episodes.

Yes, exactly. And since Kenobi is no match for Vader, there's nothing interesting about them fighting. There was not one moment of dramatic tension in the fight between Vader & Kenobi, not one split second where you thought, 'Okay, here is where Kenobi turns it around and wins this duel.'

Again, losing a fight vs. Vader isn't interesting, because almost anyone would lose a fight vs. Vader. Kenobi at his absolute best barely won against Vader.

Vader fighting someone? Oh, no! Don't tell me who wins! I'm sure it's a very close contest!

Yawn.

Vader getting reports back from the Inquisitors as a looming menace who might show up on the planet before Kenobi gets away is useful. Vader actually fighting Kenobi? Not useful or interesting at all.

Do you seriously expect me to believe you thought Kenobi might win that fight?

You got to face your demons to move forward.

Which requires Vader to be physically present? No, not in the least. And again as I already said, the MOST Vader gives you is a chance to be done with the past. There is nothing in confronting Vader that gives Kenobi motivation or hope for the future. His "demons" are something to fight against, but not something to fight FOR.

According to your logic, Vader is required for Kenobi to move forward, therefore if Vader had died on Mustafar but the Emperor survived, Kenobi would never recover because his "demon" was no longer possible to confront.

It's just not true. It doesn't make any sense. The "demon" is inside Kenobi. Vader could have been made into a fun, looming threat, never quite materializing, but as a physical antagonist Vader is worse than someone that Kenobi has more hope of actually beating.

This guy thinks episode 3 of a show is the last episode ?