No, it’s not “just plain wrong,” and you’re creating a straw man by saying I want to punish any guild without full participation. Total gp is a system that would be less prone to manipulation and would reward participation. Even matchups like you describe would be less skewed than ones like our current TW where a 200 mil gp guild is playing down to our 180 by manipulating the active gp system. And yes, many of the points raised by others above are actually valid. I happen to think your fairness claims are both overstated and flawed, but I’m not going to dismiss them out of hand.
Obviously there are multiple factors to consider. The problem with your arguments isn’t that they don’t have merit, it’s that you present them with unjustified arrogance. I realize absolutism is the hallmark of the forums, but it’s boring as kitten