My experience echos with many of the comments above. P1 is not fun and too RNG dependent, P4 is frankly a mess. P2 & P3 are generally ok (more importantly are enjoyable) and maybe need minor tweeks only
What tier or tiers did you play?
Mainly 4 although we have tried from 2 to 6. T3 and below are easy but give poor payouts, T5 and above takes far too long (in excess of a week). With 2/3 guild participation T4 can be done in 3-4 days
What GP is your Guild that is attempting the raid?
60 million GP guild
What teams you did you attempt the raid with?
JTR Resistance, Zader sith, rebel attackers, Jawas, FO
What part of the raid motivated or demotivated you to continue trying?
Motivated - the possibility of rewards
Demotivated - the actual rewards, especially for time input required. The fact that P1 and P4 are not fun and far to RNG dependant. This can be seen by the number of guild members who don't bother beyond doing a single run to score for rewards
What about the raid did you enjoy? What did you dislike about the raid?
Like - P2 and P3 are fine and enjoyable (and noticably get more buy in from other guild members), although would suggest that either armour or health needs to be toned down a little in P2 and the ability to either remove isolate OR to sooth would be a nice touch in P3 (with global cooldown when either is triggered)
Dislike - Time commitment required, takes far too long to complete for the rewards given. Mainly though P1 and P4 are just not fun. Nihilus is far too RNG dependant and if you are one of the earlier players in P4 especially the damage from bonds of weakness in P4 can be excessive (so there are 2 negative play experience mechanics against you there). Also dislike that the squad synergies and debuff abilities largely count for nothing in this.
Capital Games Team
