The Clone Wars celebration that wasn't.

"Georgemi6;c-1700313" wrote:

"CadoaBane;c-1699704" wrote:

"Roken_Fett;c-1699564" wrote:

"CadoaBane;c-1699546" wrote:
I actually see only 2 things that lead to this situation of disappointed people.
One is that expectations are high when a "celebration" is officially announced, e. g. some of us play SWTOR, too, which also runs under EA license. There are not a lot of events or celebrations at all, as of course it's a completely different type of game. But when a celebration is announced, such as the yearly Life Day Event, there's a whole month of stuff to do and prices to win.
The second thing is about the leaks... I clearly get why CG can't allow anyone to benifit from something like that. It's a matter of principles: if a leak gets confirmed and turns out to be true, the leaker will get even more attention and range if he does it the next time. If an exposed leak leads to delaying things and driving the playerbase mad, the solution should be not to leak such stuff anymore, therefore not ruin it for everyone! :|

Another thing, why do so many people want a Mace Windu rework? I understand the desire for Grievous, but we already have a lot of great Jedi in the game. Indeed, the Jedi faction now has more characters than most other factions. Plus, in the series he behaved like a hypocrite against Ahsoka, that's when I lost my respect for him, to be honest ;) .

Edit: I used a different word than "hypocrite" first, but it got censored^^ .

Because Mace is one of the most powerful Jedi ever and is probably the worst one in the game.

Same goes for Cad Bane as a bounty hunter, and his rework didn't make it much better. Or think of Bodhi Rook, the sentence he says the most often in the movie is "I am the pilot", yet he has no ship at all. This game has never been about lore logic, otherwise a Sith like Darth Nihilus, who was able to destroy whole planets, could not be a playable character at all, as noone could kill him, especially not non- force users. So we can either get mad about it, or just live with it. ;)

"CadoaBane;c-1700161" wrote:

"Roken_Fett;c-1699722" wrote:

"CadoaBane;c-1699704" wrote:

"Roken_Fett;c-1699564" wrote:

"CadoaBane;c-1699546" wrote:
I actually see only 2 things that lead to this situation of disappointed people.
One is that expectations are high when a "celebration" is officially announced, e. g. some of us play SWTOR, too, which also runs under EA license. There are not a lot of events or celebrations at all, as of course it's a completely different type of game. But when a celebration is announced, such as the yearly Life Day Event, there's a whole month of stuff to do and prices to win.
The second thing is about the leaks... I clearly get why CG can't allow anyone to benifit from something like that. It's a matter of principles: if a leak gets confirmed and turns out to be true, the leaker will get even more attention and range if he does it the next time. If an exposed leak leads to delaying things and driving the playerbase mad, the solution should be not to leak such stuff anymore, therefore not ruin it for everyone! :|

Another thing, why do so many people want a Mace Windu rework? I understand the desire for Grievous, but we already have a lot of great Jedi in the game. Indeed, the Jedi faction now has more characters than most other factions. Plus, in the series he behaved like a hypocrite against Ahsoka, that's when I lost my respect for him, to be honest ;) .

Edit: I used a different word than "hypocrite" first, but it got censored^^ .

Because Mace is one of the most powerful Jedi ever and is probably the worst one in the game.

Same goes for Cad Bane as a bounty hunter, and his rework didn't make it much better. Or think of Bodhi Rook, the sentence he says the most often in the movie is "I am the pilot", yet he has no ship at all. This game has never been about lore logic, otherwise a Sith like Darth Nihilus, who was able to destroy whole planets, could not be a playable character at all, as noone could kill him, especially not non- force users. So we can either get mad about it, or just live with it. ;)

Pretty weak argument but ok. :)

If logic is not strong enough as an argument for you, I don't know what you would like to hear ;) .
The game makers never prioritized designing character abilities matching the lore, but focused on their own ideas of balancing, that's just a fact and I only gave a few of the most obvious examples. Plus, I just think that if they start making things better in that regard, there are some other characters that would need a rework before him (while Cad Bane's rework was rather disappointing) - Following your logic, Anakin would still have to be stronger than Windu, of course.

Alright, if you want logic, you’ve come the the right place ;)

I will concede, there are some oddities in the game like nihilus, but if star wars game were 100 percent accurate, we could never have teams with rebels and sith and Jedi and resistance and a wampa working together. Sometimes they have to make those necessary scrafices. Additionally, you say that the game makers put no logic into character designs? Have you ever noticed that to beat night sisters, you kill Old Daka and they crumble, just like in TCW? Or that when Vader and Palpatine got reworked, they were perfect counters to the CLS teams of the time? Or that in the new TW bonuses, mace can instakill jango if he’s exposed Little stuff like that is hard to notice, but I suppose it’s hard to see when you have one eye closed ;)
Also, you say other characters need a rework more than mace.... name one (besides grievous) that is both worse than mace and has been requested more than mace and I will believe you. And since you are logical, back it up with evidence. I don’t know if you’ve noticed, but mace and gg have been requested as reworks for literal years now. And since your account is 10 days old, that either shows you don’t know what you’re talking about, or that you’re trolling.
Have a nice day ;)