Product: Star Wars: Galaxy of HeroesPlatform:Android PhoneWhat type of device are you experiencing the issue with? LG G2OS Version 5.0.2Ally Code: (Find it here: http://bit.ly/AllyCode ) 114-599-731What type of issue do you have? GameplayHow often does the bug occur? Often (50% - 99%)Summarize your bug TFP not critically hitting HMF 99% of the time. Steps: How can we find the bug ourselves? Play with maxed TFP against maxed HMF.Connection Type WifiPlease select your region EuropeCountry BulgariaTFP pilot is 7*, has its abilities maxed, G12 and 3G12+ pieces, 6xT6 mods. Its ship is 7*, has maxed abilities and 39.29% crit chance. Capital ship is Chimaera which gives it additional 15% crit chance. When playing against HMF TFP attacks first with its special and will almost never land a crit hit, just does regular damage. Occasionally it'll hit a weak falcon, for example 5* or one where HMF's pilots are gear10-11 and will never hit critically 7* falcon with both pilots g12 and zetas. 54.29% crit chance should give 1 out of 2, 2 out of 3 and so on successful crit hits but this is not happening. This issue seems to happen specifically when attacking HMF, against other ships TFP crits frequently. The enemy fleet doesn't have Cassian's ship, which would give crit avoidance. Usually it consists of HMF, Bossk and Bigs or Hera's ships.

@FourInstances It's my understanding that when HC does testing like that, they have much more visibility to stats and mechanics then a regular player. If they can actually see the listed critical chance and avoidance values then regardless if the number of repetitions, the values should remain unchanged. This is making me want to test and keep statsb myself though. I like a good mystery...

@crzydroid for over 50+ days I've had more than 500 battles with this fleet, the physically recorded data is the grinding of my teeth. I'm joking of course but seriously the only viable data for you would be if I recorded each and every battle on video, which you understand is impossible. Everything else is just my word and I've already given it and just think what reason might I have to lie about this? If it worked as intended wouldn't I be happily enjoying the game and collecting tons of crystals?@GladOS-013 I don't understand how the 35% @EA_HighCommand achieved are correct stats. ITF alone has 39% and 15% from the Chimaera. He didn't achieve even the ITF' stat, which ok let's say was a bad run, but where are the 15% from the Chimaera? Also if this result will not change as more battles are played then that's proof right there that something''s wrong. Obviously 35% is very different from the expected 54%. To the very least this is ground for more testing to see indeed if it was a bad run or there is more to it. My experience shows there is much more as I"m not even close to these 35% in my 500+ battles, but apparently High Command has no interest to have this mystery solved. And note it's not just me. People from my guild play the same fleet, they have noticed it, friends from other guilds have noticed it, there is another post here, which I quoted earlier in the thread on this exact same issue from someone I don't know.If you have the time and make let's say 40 battles and tell me you got anywhere near 54% success rate I'll accept that everything is ok, that we're all wrong and the game works as intended. Can you find the time for that please?The other report is this one - "Crit Chance not calculating properly in fleet "

Can someone kindly look into this and clarify what's going on?It's been a week and no one has at least acknowledged this report.

How many times do you have tried?With crits you mean the yellow numbers and with non critical hits the red ones?I ask the second one just for clarification, meaning that you are not just looking for high damage numbers or the relative healthpool loss of HMF

For the duration of 2 weeks, 10 times each day, I use refresh to climb up the ranks and am able to mostly due to using Casian's ship as reinforcement rather than relying on the TFP.It's not about the color, never paid attention to that, but about the damage dealt, critical hit makes almost double damage. Regular hits do about 39K, while crits do 66-72K which removes all protection from HMF and also some of the health. So you can say I'm looking at the digits displayed after the hit, the difference is so big that you can tell whether it was a crit hit or no.

TFP not critically hitting HMF 99% of the time.

19 Replies

GladOS-013
Hero (Retired)
6 years ago
If it's just with this specific interaction, it sounds more like some unintended "Crit Avoidance" on the Falcon, rather than the crit chance for the TIE Fighter.
Darklight_BG001
Seasoned Traveler
6 years ago
Thanks for the replies, @GladOS-013, @crzydroid and @EA_HighCommand, but I wonder where does that leave us. if it's unintended "Crit avoidance" on HMF part can it be brought back to normal level, which should be 0% as per the ship description? Do I need to report this somewhere else, is someone looking into it after I reported it here or what are the next steps?
I would like this resolved as each day I'm losing crystals because of it for refreshes and for not getting higher ranks. Rough estimate shows that I've lost about 8K crystals for the duration of 50 days since I'm running this fleet.
Thanks.
crzydroid
Hero (Retired)
6 years ago
It might be helpful if you have any tables of physically recorded rates you may have. Number of non-dodged hits on Falcon and number of crits (yellow text).
FourInstances
6 years ago
@crzydroid Shouldn't it be the other way around? The player base (including you) collected some decent amount of data which suggests some stats might not work as intended. Why asking a player to record data CG already has at hand? Devs should be able to fetch all TFP vs HMF battles from logs for a few days with ease and check the crit rate. That would be thousands of battles which @Darklight_BG001 could never provide. Only if those logs show nothing unusual it should be 1010303090s turn again to gather additional footage to prove his point valid nevertheless.
GladOS-013
Hero (Retired)
6 years ago
@FourInstances Since battles take place locally on each device (instead of on the server), I don't think CG has any logs of the specific hits. High Command said they did testing of this and saw correct stats and critical rates. It's a mystery
FourInstances
6 years ago
@GladOS-013 Hey, I know the battles take place locally. High Command talked about doing a few battles manually (which I cannot take seriously). If logs from the live game are not available test servers should do. Simulate 1000 runs of the fleet composition in question and post back to poor 1010303090. If CG does not have any logs on how the game is working that would be another mystery 😉
GladOS-013
Hero (Retired)
6 years ago
@FourInstances It's my understanding that when HC does testing like that, they have much more visibility to stats and mechanics then a regular player. If they can actually see the listed critical chance and avoidance values then regardless if the number of repetitions, the values should remain unchanged.

This is making me want to test and keep statsb myself though. I like a good mystery...
GladOS-013
Hero (Retired)
6 years ago
@GladOS-013 I did two battles with Chimaera, TIE, Poe, Hound Tooth squads tonight. My Tie critted 1 out of the 2 battles. Small sample size for sure, but very unlikely if there’s a 1% crit chance,
Darklight_BG001
Seasoned Traveler
6 years ago
@crzydroid for over 50+ days I've had more than 500 battles with this fleet, the physically recorded data is the grinding of my teeth. I'm joking of course but seriously the only viable data for you would be if I recorded each and every battle on video, which you understand is impossible. Everything else is just my word and I've already given it and just think what reason might I have to lie about this? If it worked as intended wouldn't I be happily enjoying the game and collecting tons of crystals?
@GladOS-013 I don't understand how the 35% @EA_HighCommand achieved are correct stats. ITF alone has 39% and 15% from the Chimaera. He didn't achieve even the ITF' stat, which ok let's say was a bad run, but where are the 15% from the Chimaera? Also if this result will not change as more battles are played then that's proof right there that something''s wrong. Obviously 35% is very different from the expected 54%. To the very least this is ground for more testing to see indeed if it was a bad run or there is more to it. My experience shows there is much more as I"m not even close to these 35% in my 500+ battles, but apparently High Command has no interest to have this mystery solved. And note it's not just me. People from my guild play the same fleet, they have noticed it, friends from other guilds have noticed it, there is another post here, which I quoted earlier in the thread on this exact same issue from someone I don't know.
If you have the time and make let's say 40 battles and tell me you got anywhere near 54% success rate I'll accept that everything is ok, that we're all wrong and the game works as intended. Can you find the time for that please?
The other report is this one - "Crit Chance not calculating properly in fleet "

Forum Discussion

TFP not critically hitting HMF 99% of the time.

19 Replies

Featured Places

SWGOH Technical Issues

Recent Discussions

Webstore transaction failed, still charged

Missing Coliseum level 8 3M Rewards

Deleted datacron salvage

Webstore Issues

SWGOH webstore Oops ! something went wrong.