Personally if I were doing the Sims 4 I would do this one Base Game addition.
I would take the Baking Skill that is in Get to Work and make it a BG feature, then I'd sort all the Baking recipes that are in the Cooking recipes which should have been in Baking all along. Next I'd compensate the owners of GTW by adding a few things.
- I'd make Bakery a Retail Commercial Lot Type
- The Cupcake Machine and its recipes would stay as a GTW item though, thats only fair.
- I'd add one new Lot Trait that had to do with how a Bakery smells
- As for a replacement skill - Jewel Crafting. We already have rocks & gemstones in game. I'd add a Jewel crafting work bench with stone polisher. Along with a bunch of new jewelry, and polished stone crafting items you can create
- I'd change the Retail Lot designation to have sub-designations
- Retail Lot - Art Gallery
- Retail Lot - Bakery
- Retail Lot - Book Store
- Retail Lot - Clothing Store
- Retail Lot - Electronics Store
- Retail Lot - Florist Shop (If you have Seasons & GTW)
- Retail Lot - Furniture Store
- Retail Lot - Garden Center (if you have Seasons & GTW)
- Retail Lot - Jewelry Store
- Retail Lot - Magic Store (If you have ROM & GTW)
- Retail Lot - Nectar Store (if you have Horse Ranch & GTW)
Other Items I would add in GTW
- Bakery Build/Buy Package
- Appropriately Styled Commercial Build/Buy Items (Front Door, Window, Signage, and Door Mat) in a few colors
- Bakery Clutter - A few pieces (think similar to the Sims 3 store)
- Bakers Rack
- Commercial Oven
- Refrigerated Case
- Stand Mixer
- Jewelry Store Build/Buy
- Magazine Rack & Comic Rack
- Seed Kiosk - Unlockable if you have Seasons & Get To Work
Notes
- I'd allow you to sell manure fertilizer to the Garden Center or stock it if you own the center and if you have HR and/or CL
- I'd Advertise this as a GTW Refresh which it would be that gave GTW a bunch of added value. And attract new purchasers
Win-Win for everyone including EA. Base Game gets a new skill. Recipes are sorted in a much more efficient way. GTW gets a bunch of new cool stuff but practical for its purposes. A ton of inter-pack assets. We get off EA's back about another refresh for a while.