Im on console so I couldnt use CC even if I wanted to...but I gotta say most of the CAS CC I see is not my taste, Im very, very tired of overly polished, photoshopped-esque, AI Beautyfilter-like looking anything and feel more connected and interested in the "imperfect" (which is not a synonym for ugly btw). Also most of the hair and face CC Ive seen doesnt look like the game, I am a huge fan of hairstyles in any game but when the CC looks too out of place I dont like it (have the same issue with skyrim, where I like alot of CC hairstyles but wont use them cause they look too "fake" in the game).
Anyway, rant over...no, you are not alone and to each their own.