Update. I forgot all about the frog breeding since my last post, but I just came back to it now and decided to have another go at getting that leaf frog.
So last time you said
Eggplant Frog + Spotted Leaf Frog = Leaf Frog
What really happened...
Eggplant Frog + Spotted Leaf Frog = Leopard Frog.
This time ....
Spotted Leaf Frog + Eggplant frog = Leaf frog.
YAY! I got it... so it seems that it does make a difference who the starter frog is. How sure are you that when you made the list originally, Eggplant was first? Was this random, or is the starter frog important?
To test this theory, I am going to see what happens with the only other frog I am missing... Surfer Eggplant Frog
You say...
Eggplant Frog + Surfer Leaf Frog = Surfer Eggplant Frog
What really happened...
Eggplant Frog + Surfer Leaf Frog = Surfer Eggplant Frog
Surfer Leaf Frog + Eggplant Frog = Leaf Frog
And since I have 1 spare sim to try the frog breeding with I thought I would try the SL frog + EP frog again to see if I got another leaf.... and I did! Which confirms my theory that actually A+B is not the same as B+A. Which means that all the Lists need to start again unless you are absolutely sure which order they were done in x :D (sorry)