Get famous vs island living?

Get Famous has a lot more gameplay. It also has more Build and Buy objects that you can use in almost every house. The downside is that the world is smaller than the Island Living one but it's still a nice world.

Get Famous.

In that pack you can play a sim who goes from being poor to a famous celebrity, be an actor, do livestreams and sell music.

In Island Living you can...play a career where you pick up trash...and you can swim...and...pretend that you are deep diving...
oh, and you can do small jobs...where you...go to rabbit holes and pretend that you are doing something...

but hey, at least you can build sand castles.

Get Famous 100%. Much more content, much more replayability, much more depth, much more quirkiness.

Island Living for my part.

Hmm... I could remove Get Famous but I cannot imagine playing the game without Sulani. It is one of my absolute favorite worlds! So so happy that my sims can live there.

Island living, definitely. Get famous... I didn't even play through a full generation (when I quit my Get famous save my first gen sims were still only adults) but it just get soo annoying. The Fame system really penetrates everything. It was such a relief checking the "all sims opt out of fame by default" when starting my new game. Far less of a hassle, far less interruptions in gameplay by paparazzi or fans or...

Get famous got boring so fast ! Island living here I come lol

"KaeChan2089;c-17162883" wrote:
Get Famous...I got bored after 30 minutes of IL, it should NOT be an expansion, feels nothing like one.

It feels like an apology that they didn't add enough to the Vintage Glamour

I understand why you're asking for other's opinions, but your opinions/gameplay will invariably differ from ours. I would suggest reading some comprehensive guides on both packs, with regards to features, new gameplay dynamics, build/buy, worlds etc.

Both Carl's sims 4 guides and simsvip have detailed guides.

Get Famous = gameplay
Island Living = world

Get Famous is great in terms of gameplay so I like that one more. Even though it has some annoying features.