I would have to say city living, because, although I have Get Together, I don't have any sims living in Windenburg and I only go to the community lots. The only thing I use from the pack is the hair and clothes (which are really great). The objects aren't really my style and I don't use clubs. But, I do like the townies. I tend to use them as possible spouses to my sims.
Now City Living is one of my favorites, although I might be bias because I got it on sale for $15! I love apartments and the overall theme of the city. I also have a soft spot for the pack because, without it, my legacy sim never would have met Salim Benali, her current husband (who makes very good-looking children). I also really enjoy the festivals. The CAS items are pretty good and I use quite a bit of them. I like the modern build and buy items as well. So overall, I prefer city living because it adds more to MY game, although it might be different for everyone.
