> @MaggieMarley said:
> (Quote)
>
> I don’t think so. The immortality potion stops you from dying of old age but still lets you age. That means you will end up as an elder for eternity. But a potion which froze aging would stop you from dying of old age and let you stay eternally young. That’s different enough for me and a lot of people do want it.
>
> If you don’t think it’s different, consider this: if you were told that you wouldn’t die of old age, would it matter to you whether continued to age physically? I rather think it would make a difference to you whether you had immortality with eternal youth or immortality but would spend most of eternity in the body of a very old person.
>
> Besides, the current potion of rejuvenation stops you becoming an elder if you keep taking it. So that equally makes the immortality potion redundant.
>
> And you could say that the fact we already have things such as death flowers and the reaper’s friend serum from GTW that the immortality potion is already redundant ;)
>
> I agree that they would both end up stopping your sim dying of old age (and hence being immortal in some sense) so perhaps they would need to rename the immortality potion to reflect the fact that it wasn’t the only potion which makes you immortal. Or they could call the potion which freezes aging something like “potion of eternal youth and immortality”
You seem to have misunderstood, Immunity to Dying of Old Age (What the Immortality potion does) would be a side-effect of simply not ageing therfor if you took this Potion of Everlasting Life you would automatically be immune to dying of old age simply by virtue of not ageing therefor it would make the Potion of Immortality which prevents you from dying of old age redundant.
