I don't really like to rank them because I find interest in nearly all of them. It's not an exact ranking
I don't have Eco yet so I'm not factoring it in.
Top 5 (Plus a few):
- Seasons (Amazing even though summer is my favorite)
- Cats & Dogs (They are needy but the pets complete my game and Brindleton Bay is really well done)
- Dine Out (pre-bugs)/Spa Day - I'm counting these as two because I got them at the same time. My sims like to go out.
- Jungle Adventure (I'd like more packs like this, maybe with an option to live in the worlds).
- Island Living (Yeah, it could have had more but it is gorgeous with fun activities. I enjoy that pack and world).
- StrangerVille (I know I'm an outlier but I generally liked this pack for the world, CAS/BB & quirkiness; I like playing the dusty town after the story finished as a normal place).
Packs that are less my style:
- My First Pet Stuff (I got this in a bundle and still haven't used it).
- Luxury Party Stuff (I use the chocolate fountain for weddings and a few wealthy households).
- Get To Work (Could have been done better)
- Dine Out with bugs (it's really broken)
- Supernatural themes aren't really my style, I play with some of the content but not really with the supernatural elements.
Spooky Party Stuff is not really my style but I do kind of like it. I have spooky parties in the fall when possible and use some of the stuff. I like the pumpkin carving station.)
I know some people don't like the bowling but I do. I like activity packs. I do like Parenthood and Laundry Day. I could only list my top picks. I'd like it if they add more to Outdoor Retreat but I do send sims camping at times. More vacation options are needed.
I like most of the stuff packs.
