Wow.
Ok...skinnies, I think you are all getting a little out of control. Those skinny sims are not healthy looking. They look...hmm...like they're on the verge of starvation. Think third world hungry. No one here is taking jabs at you and not a single person told you to gain weight or start eating. Everyone is talking about the topic at hand, the sims and the way they look. If you are skinny and healthy, then be the best, happiest skinny healthy that you can be. There is nothing wrong with it. You're beautiful just the way you are.
So...back to the subject. The skinny sims are way out of proportion. It looks strange. I remember seeing a skinny sim in a video when the game was introduced and I thought we could change the height because the sim looked so stretched out. I do not like the way the skinny one looks. Maybe just a tweak heavier and it wouldn't look so emaciated. As for the heavy one, well...where's the fat? That's not that bag. The tummy is barely protruding. I'd say on a scale, the skinny is freaking skinny, but the heavy one is just so so.