When the Gurus did their supernatural poll on Twitter, the way they ran it didn't do a great job of really showing which supernaturals were most wanted imo. I chose witches, but I would also really like to see fairies more so than mermaids, zombies, etc. So here I am asking each simmer who is interested, to please list in order from most wanted to least wanted the following list of supernaturals:WerewolvesFairiesWitchesGenieZombiesRobotsMermaidsImaginary FriendSuper HeroesSomething New (optional)My list:1. Witches2. Fairies3. Something New - Elves4. Super Heroes5. Werewolves6. Mermaids7. Robots8. Genie9. Zombies10. Imaginary Friend

1.Witches2.Fairies3.Mermaids4.Genie5.Something New6.Super Heroes7.Robots8.Imaginary Friend9.Werewolves10.Zombies

Give me all the occults! It's too hard to choose between them. I agree about the Twitter poll. I don't use Twitter and I fear (well, hope) the results didn't reflect the truth for most simmers... because I have been pining for werewolves since vampires. WerewolvesWitchesFairiesRobotsMermaidsZombiesGenieImaginary FriendSuper HeroesSomething New - Elves? Unicorns? Other weres?

1) Witches2) Mermaids& underwater swimming3) WerewolvesI'm surprised they were so low on the polls, they're not my favourite, but they're classic. - ^ These 3 I absolutely want4) Fairies5) Something newI like the idea of Elementals, but that could be a feature of fairies. Also, I'm desperate for better ghosts. 6) ZombiesOnly if they could somehow make them actually dangerous, without being obnoxious. One of the main appeals is all the post-apocalyptic stuff they could come with. - Cut off point where I'm not fussed7) Robots8) Superheroes9) Genie10) Imaginary Friend

I'm not overly fond of supernaturals, but I do miss witches. A lot. If they add mermaids again it would have to be with an incredible new feature to get me on board, like actually being able to live under water (including building under water). I don't know about Werewolves, they did not really do it for me in TS3. I guess they could be more interesting with the system they used in the Vampires pack with more aspects of progression in the life state.Superheroes would be difficult to implement, I think. I would expect a large amount of powers to chose from, otherwise they could get boring quickly.

my absolute favorites which would make my game complete1.Robots2.Werewolves3.REAL plantsims (a permanent state, less needs, grow/harvest offspring, free choice of haircut,...I would also like4.Witches5.Fairies6.Genie7.Super HeroesNot for or against8.Mermaids9.Imaginary FriendI will avoid10.Zombies

Supernaturals You Want | EA Forums

82 Replies

simgirl1010
Hero
7 years ago
1.Witches
2.Fairies
3.Mermaids
4.Genie
5.Something New
6.Super Heroes
7.Robots
8.Imaginary Friend
9.Werewolves
10.Zombies
annaliese39
Seasoned Ace
7 years ago
Give me all the occults! It's too hard to choose between them. I agree about the Twitter poll. I don't use Twitter and I fear (well, hope) the results didn't reflect the truth for most simmers... because I have been pining for werewolves since vampires.

Werewolves
Witches
Fairies
Robots
Mermaids
Zombies
Genie
Imaginary Friend
Super Heroes
Something New - Elves? Unicorns? Other weres?
Dreamprisoner
Seasoned Ace
7 years ago
1) Witches

2) Mermaids
& underwater swimming

3) Werewolves
I'm surprised they were so low on the polls, they're not my favourite, but they're classic.

- ^ These 3 I absolutely want

4) Fairies

5) Something new
I like the idea of Elementals, but that could be a feature of fairies. Also, I'm desperate for better ghosts.

6) Zombies
Only if they could somehow make them actually dangerous, without being obnoxious. One of the main appeals is all the post-apocalyptic stuff they could come with.

- Cut off point where I'm not fussed

7) Robots
8) Superheroes
9) Genie
10) Imaginary Friend
Netzspannung
Seasoned Ace
7 years ago
I'm not overly fond of supernaturals, but I do miss witches. A lot.
If they add mermaids again it would have to be with an incredible new feature to get me on board, like actually being able to live under water (including building under water).
I don't know about Werewolves, they did not really do it for me in TS3. I guess they could be more interesting with the system they used in the Vampires pack with more aspects of progression in the life state.
Superheroes would be difficult to implement, I think. I would expect a large amount of powers to chose from, otherwise they could get boring quickly.
atreya33
Legend
7 years ago
my absolute favorites which would make my game complete
1.Robots
2.Werewolves
3.REAL plantsims (a permanent state, less needs, grow/harvest offspring, free choice of haircut,...

I would also like
4.Witches
5.Fairies
6.Genie
7.Super Heroes

Not for or against
8.Mermaids
9.Imaginary Friend

I will avoid
10.Zombies
ValiantRedKnight
Seasoned Ace
7 years ago
My list is:
1. Faeries
2. Robots
3. Genie
4. PlantSims (something else)
5. Mermaids
6. Werewolves (basically tied with mermaids)
7. Imaginary Friends

I dislike zombies.

Also I don’t want witches or superheroes to be their own lifestates:

Witches because they look just like regular sim, and are basically exactly like them but with magic, and also you can’t change occult type in CAS.

And why shouldn’t an alien be allowed to be a superhero? Or a regular sim? Most superheroes are normal people who had something big happen to them (this also applies to super villains.) The Sims shouldn’t have to be Sky High or The Incredibles.
RememberJoy
Seasoned Ace
7 years ago
"Netzspannung;c-16826795" wrote:

I don't know about Werewolves, they did not really do it for me in TS3. I guess they could be more interesting with the system they used in the Vampires pack with more aspects of progression in the life state.

Same here. I didn't like werewolves in Sims 3, but I've since come across a lot of interesting ideas for them on this website, so they've risen on my list.

"Netzspannung;c-16826795" wrote:
Superheroes would be difficult to implement, I think. I would expect a large amount of powers to chose from, otherwise they could get boring quickly.

Yes, they would be difficult to do right, but if they were done right I think they could be an awesome addition to the game.
zvinko
7 years ago
1. Witches
2. Plant Sims- improved
3. Fairies
4. Mermaids
5. Imaginary Friend
6. Genie
7. Robots
8. Super heroes
9. Werewolves
GamingTweety
7 years ago
If I were to list
1) Witches
2) Fairies
3) Mermaids
4) Elves (Something new)
5) Super heroes
6) Werewolves
But Hate for zombies.
Hermitgirl
Seasoned Ace
7 years ago
1. Witches
2. Robots

The rest about equal and kind of in this order maybe:

Imaginary Friend (love the idea of it depends on how it's made)
Mermaids (intrigued by this)
Zombies (I'd like this if they were optional..I don't want to be annoyed by them or have to remove the pack)
Werewolves (I guess I want them to be able to do things I don't think we'd see in game)
Genie (like the idea of this wonder if this could be a freebie though.. like plant sims were)
Fairies (I don't know.. maybe?)
Super Heroes (worried how they could fight villans in game.. maybe?)