Surfer frogs super rare?

Awesome, thank you @Daephene. I'll go there next to try to get a few more. I got just one in Sylvan glade and had no luck again after like 100 more attempts, so greener pastures it is.

Edit: I stopped off at the Forgotten Grotto first and got one there too! Maybe just making this thread was the boost I needed. This sim is a YA who has completed University, and she actually started this collection as a child...