Your Favorite Goth Manor
As the title says... I honestly like the Sims 3 Goth Manor, with the Sims 4 Goth Manor a second.
Forum Discussion
I only play TS3 and TS4, but I looked the other two up and came to the conclusion that I like the one from TS3 the most. The one from TS1 looks too small to really count as a "manor", more like a bigger house. The one from TS2 looks too plain to me and the one from TS4 might look pretty, but it lacks the notorious graveyard, so I go with the TS3 version.
