I have encountered the same issue playing Life&Death. My sim wants to throw a gold costume party, which requires the deluxe Up all Night content that I don't own (I do have Spooky stuff but a gold Spooky party doesn't fulfill the goal).
I'll need to to scrap the entire list, which is a bit annoying.
Edit By Crinrict: Adjusted Title fit migrated bug report: [LD] Bucket List: Custome Party goal showing up without owning DD | EA Forums - 11700834
Archived thread had around 6 me toos
