Spruce Almighty Always Summoned

At first the tree would work as expected and I could summon Spruce Almighty and interact with him. I had my sim start a romantic relationship with him to see what would happen and after my Sim WooHoo'd with him for the first time, his tree doesn't let me "Summon" him anymore. The option to Summon him is greyed out and it says "Spruce Almighty is already summoned!" 

I spent minutes looking all around the neighborhood and I couldn't find him anywhere and when I opened the relationship tab his portrait didn't give me any options related to him being on the same lot or even in the neighborhood, such as "Focus Camera". 

I got the summoning tree reward from the fable and previous to this bug I summoned him on my home lot, but it was a different Spruce from the one in Innisgreen, so I haven't even bothered with that Spruce again. 

Is anyone else having this bug? I even tried debugging/resetting the tree in game by turning on testingcheats and have taken in and out Mods/CC, but nothing seems to be working.