Slow sensitivity when aiming to the right

When I try to turn right, my turn speed is wildly inconsistent.

Sometimes I turn at normal speed, sometimes it's slowed to a crawl, and there's no rhyme or reason to it. If I keep the stick to the right you can literally watch the speed change.

Apex is the only game that I have this issue with.

Steps taken:

Hard reset

Uninstall and reinstall

3 different controllers (I even went and bought a brand new one)

Reset controller settings to default

At this point it's gotten so bad the game is almost unplayable.