at RB, WR, and DB in Dynasty recruiting. Was a MAJOR problem in 14 and appears to be again. It's not realistic.

Also, tons of black dudes with blonde pompadour hair lol. This is why it’s important to let us customize everything about the game generated players!

@EA_Kent Just wanted to give this a bump because it's a big deal as far as realism, and if Madden can get it right with it's auto-generated draft classes (and it does - quite well in fact), there's literally no reason for this to be the same problem it was in 14.Only about 1 in 25 RBs should be white dudes, maybe 1 in 4 or 5 receivers, about 1 in 5 safeties, about 1 in 4 DEs and DTs, and maybe, MAYBE, 1 in 50 cornerbacks. And easy on the beards. I'm recruiting guys that look like grandpas.

Yeah this is flat out garbage. Shouldn’t have the university of Miami and have an all white secondary. Sorry; not sorry. It’s factual. Go find me a year they had one and I’ll be quiet.

This is the biggest immersion breaker for me. I have been restarting a ton of dynasty’s to try and find a reasonably realistic class. Here are some stats on a few I just did. One was 16 of the top 20 players were white and 38/top 50 white. Another one i did was 33/top 50 white. I am staring at a recruiting class right now where 21/top 30 Rb’s are white and 18/top 30 WR’s. How does this compare to real life?? In this year’s rivals 2025 recruiting class, 47 of the top 50 players are black. Absolutely insane that they are so incredibly off here. This should be a simple % formula of what to generate. Also have they outlawed shaving in college? 90% of the recruits have beards. Interesting choice for a bunch of 18-22 year olds. Most of the recruits look like long-haul truck drivers.

@manicmusician69 Lol so many with Nigerian names too it’s hilarious

Waaaaaaaaaay too many white dudes

19 Replies

ncballer5
7 months ago
@manicmusician69 Lol so many with Nigerian names too it’s hilarious
btmnyj811
Seasoned Veteran
7 months ago
Also, tons of black dudes with blonde pompadour hair lol. This is why it’s important to let us customize everything about the game generated players!
ngo0525
7 months ago
@btmnyj811: Was wondering if I was the only one who noticed this. And way too many black guys with dreads. EA says that it’s committed to diversity and inclusion, but either generates black guys with flowing blond hair, or black guys with dreads (stereotype). As if black men don’t wear a variety of hairstyles. There should be more fades and low cuts included in the assortment of hairstyles.
manicmusician69
7 months ago
@EA_Kent Just wanted to give this a bump because it's a big deal as far as realism, and if Madden can get it right with it's auto-generated draft classes (and it does - quite well in fact), there's literally no reason for this to be the same problem it was in 14.
Only about 1 in 25 RBs should be white dudes, maybe 1 in 4 or 5 receivers, about 1 in 5 safeties, about 1 in 4 DEs and DTs, and maybe, MAYBE, 1 in 50 cornerbacks. And easy on the beards. I'm recruiting guys that look like grandpas.
Canadeion
7 months ago
@manicmusician69 Let's be honest, EA puts black women as referees in their NHL game. It used to be "if it's in the game, it's in the game..."

Now, it's "if it's woke BS, it's in the game."
xLEMx
6 months ago
bump. ratio of black/white at skill positions is unrealistic. too many black players with blonde hair/facial hair. too many players with ridiculous facial hair. too many dynasty coach choices with facial hair (or perhaps just not enough without).
WrathOfHades85
Rising Ace
6 months ago
@manicmusician69 I recruited 3 black kickers and 3 black punters, without even realizing it. I also recruited a white DT named Jose Mama, and I refuse to not use a hard J and just call him Jo.
xLEMx
6 months ago
forgot about the ratio of black/white for kickers and punters. also way off. thanks.
definitely jo.
Bjkam1208
6 months ago
Of the top 32 5☆ players, 22 are white. LOL. Oh well! Let me grab a few!🤣🤣🤣
danishram
6 months ago
Giving this a bump, please fix EA