Key Moments onside kicks

I've had a lot of issues with recommended plays, sometimes only giving me one or two options. However the by far most troubling issue has been key moments onside kicks. When simming, it will prompt me when an opponent is kicking an onside kick. However, if I try to jump in, it will not allow me to select any plays. It completely removes all plays, and auto selects regular kickoff return, forcing you to lose the possession.