The game as a whole
To the EA Sports Development Team,
I’m writing this message as someone who has spent years playing Madden and NCAA College Football. I’ve supported these franchises for a long time, but I’m reaching the point where I genuinely believe this may be my last year playing EA Sports football games.
I didn’t purchase Madden this year because I believe its gameplay has become progressively worse. Unfortunately, College Football 27 appears to be heading down that same path, and that’s extremely disappointing.
My biggest issue is the inconsistency and lack of intelligence displayed by AI-controlled players on my team compared to the CPU opponent.
When playing against the CPU, the opposing players consistently seem to make the correct decisions. Their defenders react properly, recognize plays, cover receivers, pursue the football, and execute assignments with impressive awareness.
However, the AI-controlled players on my team frequently do the exact opposite.
My defenders take terrible pursuit angles, fail to react to obvious situations, abandon assignments, and make decisions that simply don’t make football sense. Offensive linemen miss blocks, players fail to recognize what’s happening directly in front of them, and defensive backs often seem completely unaware of their responsibilities.
What’s even more frustrating is that these same players perform their assignments correctly during practice.
In practice, my players recognize their responsibilities, execute their assignments, and react appropriately. Yet when I enter an actual game, those same players suddenly behave as though they’ve forgotten how to play football.
Why?
Why should the CPU opponent consistently demonstrate intelligent football behavior while the AI-controlled players on my team struggle with basic football fundamentals?
Why should players execute properly during practice but suddenly lose that same awareness during games?
This isn’t simply about winning or losing. I don’t expect to win every game, and I don’t want the game made easier. I want a fair, competitive football simulation where both teams operate under the same standards of artificial intelligence.
The blocking mechanics are another major concern. Offensive linemen frequently ignore defenders directly in their path, fail to engage obvious blocking assignments, or execute animations that make absolutely no sense in the context of the play.
Defensive gameplay suffers from similar problems. Players fail to react to the football, take unrealistic angles, and sometimes appear deliberately unresponsive while the CPU opponent executes with far greater consistency.
Player animations also seem to take priority over actual football logic. Too often, the outcome of a play feels dictated by predetermined animations rather than player ratings, positioning, awareness, or the decisions made by the person holding the controller.
This creates the impression that the game is controlling the outcome rather than allowing football intelligence and user skill to determine what happens.
That is not what a football simulation should feel like.
I also believe the Dynasty and Franchise experiences deserve more attention. These modes should provide depth, realism, and meaningful football strategy, but none of those features can compensate for inconsistent gameplay on the field.
What makes this especially frustrating is the potential of College Football.
For years, many of us wanted the college football franchise to return. When it finally did, there was excitement about having an alternative to Madden. Unfortunately, I’m watching College Football gradually develop some of the same gameplay problems that made me stop purchasing Madden.
That’s incredibly disappointing.
I understand that developing a football video game is complicated. However, these franchises have been around for decades, and basic football intelligence, consistent AI behavior, proper blocking assignments, and realistic defensive reactions should not continue to be recurring problems.
I’m not asking for perfection.
I’m asking for consistency, fairness, accountability, and a football game that actually rewards football knowledge and intelligent decision-making.
If my players have the ratings and awareness to execute their responsibilities correctly in practice, those abilities should not mysteriously disappear during actual games.
If the CPU opponent can recognize plays, react intelligently, and execute assignments properly, my AI-controlled teammates should be capable of doing the same.
The game should not feel like the CPU is operating under a completely different set of rules.
EA Sports needs to seriously evaluate the direction of these franchises.
Longtime players are becoming frustrated, and simply releasing another game every year without adequately addressing these fundamental gameplay issues is not good enough.
I have supported these football franchises for years, but my patience is wearing thin.
I skipped Madden this year because of the direction that franchise has taken. Now I’m watching College Football follow a similar path.
If meaningful improvements aren’t made, College Football 27 may very well be my last EA Sports football game.
I genuinely hope the development team takes feedback like this seriously because these games have the potential to be much better than what we’re currently experiencing.
Sincerely,
A longtime EA Sports football player