Forum Discussion

Silencer737's avatar
2 years ago

Can some one explain how womens ratings calculated/earned?

I suspect that we are measuring with two different standards here for women vs men's rating or some one has to tell me better. I would like this clarified so we know the game mechanics and what to expect from real life performances being reflected in the game and how realistic it will be going forward, it will be a desciding factor for my purchasing descision for this installment.


for example kessler is 90 rated. being higher rated than yaya toure, litmanen, rui costa, kompany, ramires, rosicky, berbatov. to name a few, I would almost say it is disrespectful to these players, fans, clubs, carreers and their herritage.


we have not seen anywhere near their level of play or international reputation from these ladies in real life performances, so where do these ratings come from? do their body type perform worse to compensate with stats or what is going on here?

for example, I remember you used to advertise to use real life men player's their sprint times to calculate their pace. I don't see how the female body can be physically at the same level. it is newtonically not possible.

it is also a giant dissrespect for some of the bronze rated men and clubs rating, who have proven on the field to be a better level than some of the high gold rated women by beating them and playing better.

16 Replies

  • I can't believe the womens ratings. RIP Ultimate team ,

    I'm gone ,two of the best three midfielders women ?, thought it was Ultimate Team , not Ultimate Farce. 

    There is no excuse for this , Arsenal under 15's beat the United States women's world champions 5-0.

    CBA anymore , not playing , not responding , goodbye 

  • RadioShaqs's avatar
    RadioShaqs
    Hero
    2 years ago

    Looks like in the new pitch notes women will get special cards like the non top 5 men’s leagues. So they will likely fall behind in ratings. 

  • bjornini's avatar
    bjornini
    2 years ago

    I can't believe we're still holding this discussion 

  • RoscoSCM's avatar
    RoscoSCM
    2 years ago

    There is however a degree of reality to the vast majority of men's rankings. Sure some players are overrated, others underrated and some of the novelty cards are outright ridiculous. So it's realism touched with some ridiculous novelty. 

    But in general the players in the top leagues are the best as you'd expect. 

    As someone whose been playing FIFA since its debut on the Megadrive and who has solely played FUT in recent years, I'll simply be swerving this game. There is nothing less realistic in football than women being on the same pitch as men. The ratings speak for themselves and utterly undermine any claims of realism that EA repeatedly make. 

    I just hope EA don't also try this nonsense in Madden, UFC etc etc

  • xsjdjg8vuydb's avatar
    xsjdjg8vuydb
    2 years ago

    Your answer is complete * because people have complained about the ratings every year.  But now its so ridiculous it cant be not stated that it is for political reasons and not for sports.  Quit with your feminism this guys argument is 100% correct.  So is your comment about the ratings of GKs being STs but you trying to say because its women its somehow guys trying to hate women is stupid.  Knock it off.  I am a advocate for women but I am not going to say his argument isn't correct just because spanish coaches still live in the 50's.

About FC 24 General Discussion

Discuss the latest news and game information around EA SPORTS FC™ 24 in the community forums.9,173 PostsLatest Activity: 4 hours ago