Re: "Already have an evolution version of this player" error

They won’t. They haven’t even acknowledged the bug and chances are good that they never will. As long as it doesn’t interfere with their ideals of making money it’s a backburner and they’ll get to it when they get to it

@EA_LeonSK

Platform: PS5

Account: ChrisF22

Evolution you're trying to activate: Generous Goalscorer

Name, Rating, and Version of the Item you're selecting for this Evolution: Eddie Nketiah - Evolution Level 2, Path: TOTY Striker Prospect, Weak Foot, Skill Moves - 84 rated.

Do you have other versions of the same player? If yes, mention them.

- No, it did look like it would allow me to enter the TOTW Eddie Nketiah despite having the evolved version already, but I have since discarded that one and the base gold version.

Did you discard another Evo item of that player in the past?

- Yes, I used to have a previously evolved Eddie Nketiah from the Trailblazers Striker evolution (86 rated), which I used in an SBC in order to start the latest Evolution version I have now.

Error message received when you try to select the player:

You already have an evolution version of this player.

Screenshot of the m essage.

Please see attached.

Thanks for your help. 

Thank you, @22ChrisF22, for the details.

@ByShadir, do you remember if you also had an evolved Item of Bernardo Silva you submitted into an SBC in the past?

• Platform: PS5
• Account: bulldogmorgan
• Evolution you're trying to activate: down the right side
• Name, Rating, and Version of the Item you're selecting for this Evolution: Risa Shimizu, 83 Ovr, FS right back power up evolution
• Do you have other versions of the same player? No
• Did you discard another Evo item of that player in the past? Yes
• Error message received when you try to select the player: you already have an evolution version of this player

I quicksold the card in question, to then recover the card in an attempt to fix the bug, but unfortunately that created a new problem. The card now crashes the game whenever I try to claim the card from the unclaimed card section in Ultimate team

I cannot submit my Pedro Neto in this evolution either, he is now 80 rated, I only put him into the right star evolution. I did discard his 87 centurion sharp shooter in the past because I wanted him with 5* skills. I currently only have this neto evolution he is toty honourable mentions rarity from the completed right star evolution. Error message: "You already have an Evolution version of this player."

• Platform: PS5
• Account: lfcnellson34
• Evolution you're trying to activate: generous goalscorer
• Name, Rating, and Version of the Item you're selecting for this Evolution: nunez, 85, Skill moves Evo
• Do you have other versions of the same player? If yes, mention them. No
• Did you discard another Evo item of that player in the past? Yes
• Error message received when you try to select the player: 1st March
• Screenshot of the message.

• Platform: PS5
• Account: lfcnellson34
• Evolution you're trying to activate: generous goalscorer
• Name, Rating, and Version of the Item you're selecting for this Evolution: nunez, 85, Skill moves Evo
• Do you have other versions of the same player? If yes, mention them. No
• Did you discard another Evo item of that player in the past? Yes
• Error message received when you try to select the player: 1st March
• Screenshot of the message.

Platform: PC

Account: ByShadir

Evolution you're trying to activate: Pick it up (expires in an hour)

Name, Rating, and Version of the Item you're selecting for this Evolution: Bernardo Silva gold 88

Do you have other versions of the same player? No

Did you discard another Evo item of that player in the past? Yes

Error message received when you try to select the player: You already have an evolution version of this player

Error message: You already have an evolution version of this player

• Platform: PC
• Account: impecanable17
• Evolution you're trying to activate: Generous goalscorer
• Name, Rating, and Version of the Item you're selecting for this Evolution: Darwin Nunez, 85, Skill MovesTraining evo
• Do you have other versions of the same player? No
• Did you discard another Evo item of that player in the past? Yes, I submitted a Nunez Founders evo into an SBC
• Error message received when you try to select the player: "An unexpected error occurred. Please try again." on web app. On EAFC24 "You already have an evolution version of this player"
• Screenshot of the message.

• Platform: PC.
• Account: KINGKAIGOAT.
• Evolution you're trying to activate: Fantasy FC Assisting Winger.
• Name, Rating, and Version of the Item you're selecting for this Evolution: Gabriel Martinelli, 84 Overall, Gold Rare.
• Do you have other versions of the same player? If yes, mention them. NO
• Did you discard another Evo item of that player in the past? Yes, but it was multiple months ago.
• Error message received when you try to select the player: Unexpected error occurred. Please try again later.
• Screenshot of the message.

<span;>Platform: PS5
<span;>Account: rapperbrot
<span;>Evolution you're trying to activate: Fantasy FC Assisting Winger
<span;>Name, Rating, and Version of the Item
<span;>you're selecting for this Evolution: Robin Hack- Rating:84- Evolution Level 2 [and Toty nominee (Bug)]
<span;>Do you have other versions of the same
<span;>player? Ifyes, mention them: Silver Card 72 Rating
<span;>Did you discard another Evo item of that
<span;>player in the past?: Yes, to start new with him
<span;>Error message received when you try to
<span;>select the player: You already have an evolution version of this player
<span;>Screenshot of the message.

• Platform: Ps5
• Account: Wafflemaster72
• Evolution you're trying to activate: Generous Goalscorer
• Name, Rating, and Version of the Item you're selecting for this Evolution: Nketiah 83 Evo 
• Do you have other versions of the same player? No
• Did you discard another Evo item of that player in the past? No
• Error message received when you try to select the player: Failed to move items
• Screenshot of the message.

• Platform: Xbox 
• Account: LJ Bolton
• Evolution you're trying to activate: Down the right side and Generous goalscorer
• Name, Rating, and Version of the Item you're selecting for this Evolution: Conor Bradley (77 evo) and Dion Charles (68 common silver)
• Do you have other versions of the same player? No other versions currently in club neither do I have any in discard recovery.
• Did you discard another Evo item of that player in the past? Yes. I previously discarded an evo of both of these cards months ago.
• Error message received when you try to select the player: On console “you already have evolution of this player” and on companion app “an unexpected error occurred. Please try again.”
• Screenshot of the message.

Platform: Xbox One

Account: Nosciturasociis

Evolution: Generous Goalscorer

Name, Rating, and Version:  Armando Broja, 84 overall, Evolutions II (completed), Playstyle+ = powerheader

Other versions in club: None

Discard previous Evo item: yes, I submitted a prior Evo version of Broja in an SBC, I think

Error message: “You already have an Evolution of this player.” 
I took a photo, but cannot upload because the file size is too large. 

• Platform: Playstation
• Account:Abdul_1212
• Evolution you're trying to activate: Fut Champ Evolution
• Name, Rating, and Version of the Item you're selecting for this Evolution: Vivien Endemann 76 rated honorable mention
• Do you have other versions of the same player? If yes, mention them. NO
• Did you discard another Evo item of that player in the past?I put a previous 84 version of her into a sbc a month ago
• Error message received when you try to select the player: Already have another version of this player 
•  I quick sold her to try fix the bug but now i can't store her into the club because the game thinks its a dupilicate when i don't have another version of an evolution of her in my club

I cannot evo my 85 Darwin as well when he fits all the requirements. When can this be fixed? 

 Platform: Xbox

Account: terryaky

Evolution you're trying to activate: Generous Goalscorer

Name, Rating, and Version of the Item you're selecting for this Evolution: Darwin Nunez 85 Rated Evolutions II

Do you have other versions of the same player? Yes, Standard gold but have discarded that gold in the past to try and fix the issue with no luck.

Did you discard another Evo item of that player in the past? Yes, I beleive I put another evo version in an sbc a few months ago

Error message received when you try to select the player: "You already have an Evolution version of this player" 

I too have tried to discard and recover this Nunez card only for it to get stuck in my duplicates where all I can do is discard it again.

I have also tried putting the standard gold version of Nunez into the same evolution after I had discarded the evo version only to get the same "You already have an Evolution version of this player" message.

• Platform: Xbox Series X
• Account: KIA5175
• Evolution you're trying to activate: Nunez
• Name, Rating, and Version of the Item you're selecting for this Evolution: Nunez 85 completed evo
• Do you have other versions of the same player? A gold 82 rated one and one I put into an SBC that was an evo 
• Did you discard another Evo item of that player in the past?
• yes
• Error message received when you try to select the player: already have an evolution for this player
• Screenshot of the message.
• See attached 

Accepted as a solution for visibility

Hey all,

We can read from your post you're receiving an error mentioning you already have an Evolution version for that player. To investigate this issue, please share the following info:

• Platform: xbox s/x
•  
• Account: Giiza x
•  
• Evolution you're trying to activate: generous goalscorer
•  
• Name, Rating, and Version of the Item you're selecting for this Evolution: Armando Broja, 84, Evolutions II

• Do you have other versions of the same player? NO
•  
• Did you discard another Evo item of that player in the past? Yes. Welcome to evo first ever evo card. That I later discarded or put into a sbc
•  
• Error message received when you try to select the player: you already have an evolution version of this player.

• Platform: Xbox Series S
• Account: Beeb8245
• Evolution you're trying to activate:Generous Goalscorer
• Name, Rating, and Version of the Item you're selecting for this Evolution: Hojlund, 83, Evolutions II
• Do you have other versions of the same player? Yes, 89 future stars and 76 base card.
• Did you discard another Evo item of that player in the past? Yes
• Error message received when you try to select the player: You already have an Evolution version of this player
• Screenshot of the message.

• Platform: PS5
• Account: SteveArr
• Evolution you're trying to activate: Generous Goalscorer
• Name, Rating, and Version of the Item you're selecting for this Evolution: 81 Kyogo Furuhashi, Founders Evolution, FC Founders Upgrade chain
• Do you have other versions of the same player? No
• Did you discard another Evo item of that player in the past? Yes, I discarded the Welcome to Evolutions version during early access
• Error message received when you try to select the player: "You already have an evolution version of this player."
• To try and fix the bug I discarded my evolution and now I am unable to send him back to the club after quicksell recovering him.

I really hope this can all be sorted before the Generous Goalscorer evolution expires otherwise I will be seriously considering asking for a refund.