Forum Discussion

AlanK_Yeet's avatar
AlanK_Yeet
Seasoned Newcomer
8 months ago

From FIFA to Farce: My Final Whistle

I've been playing FIFA since I was six. My brother and I grew up with FIFA 98, and from FIFA 08 onwards, we made it a tradition to buy every new release. It wasn't just a game — it was part of our ritual, our bond.

But ever since FIFA 19, that bond has been tested — and not by opponents, but by the game itself. The gameplay has steadily collapsed under the weight of its own neglect. From cartoonish glitches like players suddenly turning on hyperspeed and zipping across a fifth of the pitch, to broken mechanics that feel less like a football sim and more like slapstick. Referees make decisions as if they're closing their eyes and spinning a wheel. Headers — once a real attacking threat — have been neutered into irrelevance; every cross is either easily intercepted or aimlessly launched into orbit, regardless of timing or positioning. And then there’s the quick sim feature — a supposedly helpful tool that instead feels like a passive-aggressive troll. Sim a match and watch your team collapse spectacularly, with scripted-seeming losses that defy logic, squad ratings, and even common sense. It’s hard not to feel like it’s intentionally broken — as if designed to frustrate you into playing manually and stretching out your hours, your patience, and your microtransaction potential.

What hurts most isn’t just the poor quality — it’s the indifference. Every year, EA asks for more money, only to deliver a product that feels less finished, less cared for. The same bugs remain. New ones are introduced. Feedback is ignored. And all of it is wrapped in the kind of polish that masks a rotting core.

At this point, EA FC doesn’t feel like a football game. It feels like an annual tax on fans’ nostalgia. And frankly, it’s exhausting. I genuinely hope FIFA finds a new developer and builds a game that finally puts EA FC out of its misery. No one deserves to keep playing a title so soulless, so creatively bankrupt, and so shamelessly marketed.

Until then, consider this my final whistle.

2 Replies

  • cCiIcCo's avatar
    cCiIcCo
    Rising Adventurer
    8 months ago

    Not a single game mode makes fun anymore, not a single mode is rewarding and I am done with it, for good! The last patch did it for me. I can't control my team offensively and defensively. My opponents can do whatever they want, pass wherever they want, everything gets to the receiver anyways. They are faster, stronger, unfailable, and every single one was spamming the Griddy!!! I almost threw my console out of the window

  • I completely agree with everything you've said. EA have, in their hubris, turned a once great football game, into a pack opening sim for kids. It's no longer the FIFA game we grew up with. It's just a hollow casino with some of the most inconsistent and sweaty game modes to frustrate you into buying their packs. To be honest, I think the franchise is dead. As a company, EA are in a death spiral. They will be banking on their sports titles to prop them up. We will never have the game we had.

Featured Places

Node avatar for FC 25 General Discussion

FC 25 General Discussion

Discuss the latest news and game information around EA SPORTS FC™ 25 in the community forums.Latest Activity: 8 hours ago
8,105 Posts