Error when selecting reward at lvl 40 season pass

I unlocked lvl 40 in the season pass and i would've liked to get the icon pick. But when i clicked X instead of getting to choose between Firmino, the 87*10 or icon pick, i just got Firmino. Normally the screen pops up where you can you one of the 3 but i didn't get any option here. If possible i would like to get compensation.

It happened at approximately 11 am, on PC through steam.