Armorer kit reveal?

"Iy4oy4s;c-2216443" wrote:

"ShaggyB;c-2216423" wrote:

"RTS;c-2216419" wrote:

"Gifafi;c-2216370" wrote:
wait a minute. If you're an engineer and teach your kid everything you learned and know, how is he not an engineer? That's how jobs worked for thousands of years (and sometimes still do).

Because the real world is different than fiction. Nobody has ever "been" a job that requires a high level degree just because they learned it from their parent(s).

You're not a doctor just because your parent was and taught you what they know - it's not how it works.

Feudal systems worked like that for years. A blacksmith would have an apprentice. Said person would learn said job hands on and then take it over or go open their own shop in a different village.

So you are completely wrong when you use an absolute like "Nobody has ever".... because a bunch of people in history have. That may not be how modern times in first world countries work today... but history covers a lot of time...

True, however, I’m comparing the Jedi order to any other organization that has a similar structure. To become an engineer or doctor, you must go through training and prove your knowledge to a governing body. Once that body has accepted your work, then you become what you set out to become. Same as a Jedi.
Once the Jedi order fell, technically, there can be no more Jedi in the traditional sense, which is why I don’t believe that Luke is a Jedi until after he finds the texts, studies them, and restarts the order....then Ben happened and boom, no more new order, therefore, Luke is ,indeed, the last Jedi.

If Yoda and OB are alive, and were part of that governing body, then the order is still alive and Yoda can anoint the title to Luke.