Can we have a clone rework?

"jkray622;c-1780541" wrote:

"Riffinator;c-1780459" wrote:

"jkray622;c-1780454" wrote:

"Riffinator;c-1780445" wrote:

"Droideka;c-1780442" wrote:

"Javick_Starage;c-1780440" wrote:

"Riffinator;c-1780433" wrote:

"jkray622;c-1780429" wrote:

"Riffinator;c-1780427" wrote:

"Droideka;c-1780382" wrote:

"Roopehunter;c-1780377" wrote:
No, please.
Theyre standard foot soldiers, brave and loyal, but clearly not able to fight against jedi or sith masters on their own.

Can’t fight against Jedi on their own, yet killed far more Jedi than any other force has?

lmao this, remember order 66?

Order 66 was not "fighting Jedi" - it was shooting them (often in the back) unexpectedly while they were in vulnerable positions. The Jedi were probably emotionally compromised too, as their trusted loyal allies turned on them, leading to distractions.

If those same Jedi had come face to face with the clones in an actual battle, it would have likely been very different.

Pong Krell

That was a great episode! Was he killed by the clones? (After slaughtering like a bunch of them)

Spoiler alert for this CW episode







No, he was stunned by one of them and imprisoned. They were forced to retreat from the planet as the Separatists were pushing them back hard, and one of the clones shot him while he was restrained in his cell. So he was killed by a clone, just not in battle.

He was still captured by clones

Sure, if you can add a Vixus to the Clone Squad.

So because they used tactics and local creatures to capture him it doesn't count? Sure the creature held him down but they still needed to get him over there so it could.

It just shows that enough RNG can allow a whole bunch of clones to capture a Jedi.

There aren't really parallels between true lore and the game in terms of "effectiveness." I was arguing that Clones "killed more Jedi than any other faction" through betrayal, not actual combat - and a single instance of clones capturing or killin one Jedi does not mean that the exception proves the rule.

Clones were effective at what the did, but they weren't Jedi hunters.

And we aren't asking them to be good against jedi but with them. To take on Droids, not the jedi. And to do that they need a rework currently.

Clones definitely need a faction-pass (in a few months, after Droids and Grievous have had their time in the spot-light), but I'd really like to see a rework for the older Jedi in the game first. The new ones are fantastic, obviously, and GMY, too, after his rework, but they still need to give some attention to Anakin (the frakkin' Chosen One), Mace Windu, Qui-Gon Jin, Ahsoka, Plo Koon, etc.

Fix those guys first, then get the Clones in order, then pretty much all will be well.

"Val_Galahadred;c-1780664" wrote:
Clones definitely need a faction-pass (in a few months, after Droids and Grievous have had their time in the spot-light), but I'd really like to see a rework for the older Jedi in the game first. The new ones are fantastic, obviously, and GMY, too, after his rework, but they still need to give some attention to Anakin (the frakkin' Chosen One), Mace Windu, Qui-Gon Jin, Ahsoka, Plo Koon, etc.

Fix those guys first, then get the Clones in order, then pretty much all will be well.

Agreed, love to see “lesser Jedi characters” get some attention.

General Kenobi, Anakin and Ahsoka should have more synergy and essentially be the light side triumvirate, especially since they taught everyone they met how to take down droids

Yes please

I would love this.

No, please.
Theyre standard foot soldiers, brave and loyal, but clearly not able to fight against jedi or sith masters on their own.

oh yes please, i would love that!

"jkray622;c-1780429" wrote:

"Riffinator;c-1780427" wrote:

"Droideka;c-1780382" wrote:

"Roopehunter;c-1780377" wrote:
No, please.
Theyre standard foot soldiers, brave and loyal, but clearly not able to fight against jedi or sith masters on their own.

Can’t fight against Jedi on their own, yet killed far more Jedi than any other force has?

lmao this, remember order 66?

Order 66 was not "fighting Jedi" - it was shooting them (often in the back) unexpectedly while they were in vulnerable positions. The Jedi were probably emotionally compromised too, as their trusted loyal allies turned on them, leading to distractions.

If those same Jedi had come face to face with the clones in an actual battle, it would have likely been very different.

“I can only protect you, I can’t fight a war for you” Qui Gon Gin.

The concept is about numbers vs talent. Sure 5 Jedi vs 5 clones Jedi should win. But when you stack up more numbers Jedi can win.

That’s what the separatist faction is sort of about. B1 showing waves of endless droid.

"Riffinator;c-1780433" wrote:

"jkray622;c-1780429" wrote:

"Riffinator;c-1780427" wrote:

"Droideka;c-1780382" wrote:

"Roopehunter;c-1780377" wrote:
No, please.
Theyre standard foot soldiers, brave and loyal, but clearly not able to fight against jedi or sith masters on their own.

Can’t fight against Jedi on their own, yet killed far more Jedi than any other force has?

lmao this, remember order 66?

Order 66 was not "fighting Jedi" - it was shooting them (often in the back) unexpectedly while they were in vulnerable positions. The Jedi were probably emotionally compromised too, as their trusted loyal allies turned on them, leading to distractions.

If those same Jedi had come face to face with the clones in an actual battle, it would have likely been very different.

Pong Krell

That was a great episode! Was he killed by the clones? (After slaughtering like a bunch of them)

"Javick_Starage;c-1780440" wrote:

"Riffinator;c-1780433" wrote:

"jkray622;c-1780429" wrote:

"Riffinator;c-1780427" wrote:

"Droideka;c-1780382" wrote:

"Roopehunter;c-1780377" wrote:
No, please.
Theyre standard foot soldiers, brave and loyal, but clearly not able to fight against jedi or sith masters on their own.

Can’t fight against Jedi on their own, yet killed far more Jedi than any other force has?

lmao this, remember order 66?

Order 66 was not "fighting Jedi" - it was shooting them (often in the back) unexpectedly while they were in vulnerable positions. The Jedi were probably emotionally compromised too, as their trusted loyal allies turned on them, leading to distractions.

If those same Jedi had come face to face with the clones in an actual battle, it would have likely been very different.

Pong Krell

That was a great episode! Was he killed by the clones? (After slaughtering like a bunch of them)

Spoiler alert for this CW episode







No, he was stunned by one of them and imprisoned. They were forced to retreat from the planet as the Separatists were pushing them back hard, and one of the clones shot him while he was restrained in his cell. So he was killed by a clone, just not in battle.