GAC feature

Half of MAW alliance players dislike this new option
Thats remove all fun from GAC
Now no reasons for theorycrafting, new tactics etc...and without it this game will boring
That’s ugly option

Do you honestly believe that this (very ameteurisch) implementation of a battle log is of any help to others?

People who use swgoh.gg are usually already advanced in the terms of gameplay mechanics. Otherwise they wouldn't even research more information regarding the game. And even in that case the log only shows the latest teams that actually win or lose, meaning if the "win" required two or more teams, then only the last team will be shown there.Helpful? I seriously doubt it.

Besides, there is no information regarding stats or mods.That would require you to jump back and forth between the pages, bringing you closer to insanity than Cthulu ever could ;)

In fact you can find much more valuable information (regarding counters) on Youtube or major SWGOH related sites.

PS: Sorry for my English (second language)

@Cyricus well mate, you might be in the bracket, where people use only standard teams to battle each other and you can find most counters on youtube, but lot’s of people have to play every round under quite different conditions, your post says for you that you are an amateur here)

If we're always just negative about everything new it's no wonder we don't get new content ;-). See it as a chance to scout your opponent, just like you could in sports.

Let’s do the same feature for TW and see what TI and MAW say?

"darthjj_G1A;c-2026901" wrote:
@Cyricus well mate, you might be in the bracket, where people use only standard teams to battle each other and you can find most counters on youtube, but lot’s of people have to play every round under quite different conditions, your post says for you that you are an amateur here)

Nonsense. If you believe this game to be rocket science then ... well, no, it is not. In fact your post shows that you didn't even actually check out that battle log on swgoh so far regarding the information it offers. It is totally useless in its current form.

Why?

a) Only shows the actual winning team (even if it took you 2 or 3 tries to win, so the first team is missing)
b) There is no info regarding mods or stats
c) There is better information available on the net
d) Hell, even checking out your opponent in game and apply some logical deducing provides more info that swgoh battle logs ("Oh, no Geos in first rows? Must be logical you can find it in the last row then on defence, right?)
e) If you shuffle your setup (front/back offence/defense) a history log won't help

It doesn't even identify cheaters because of a) and missing raw data (meaning damage per round for example).

But please feel free to enlighten me on WHY it is such a bad thing to have (seriously). Because, well, your initial post lacks an actual argument and shows only your personal opinion.

"alexnikkel22;c-2026895" wrote:
Half of MAW alliance players dislike this new option
Thats remove all fun from GAC
Now no reasons for theorycrafting, new tactics etc...and without it this game will boring
That’s ugly option

Of course half of MAW dislike this new function, because it shows up just how many of them and how often they've been colluding with opponents to ensure high scores!!

"Cyricus;c-2026947" wrote:

"DarjeloSalas;c-2026939" wrote:

"Cyricus;c-2026917" wrote:

"darthjj_G1A;c-2026901" wrote:
@Cyricus well mate, you might be in the bracket, where people use only standard teams to battle each other and you can find most counters on youtube, but lot’s of people have to play every round under quite different conditions, your post says for you that you are an amateur here)

Nonsense. If you believe this game to be rocket science then ... well, no, it is not. In fact your post shows that you didn't even actually check out that battle log on swgoh so far regarding the information it offers. It is totally useless in its current form.

Why?

a) Only shows the actual winning team (even if it took you 2 or 3 tries to win, so the first team is missing)
.

You're wrong on that one...

https://swgoh.gg/p/343174317/gac-history/?gac=2&r=2

I took 2 attempts to defeat opponent's DR in rd 2 of final GA in the last GAC.

You can see both attempts on there.

Hmm, let's put it this way then: For my own battles there are some attempts on attack missing (i know because i had two connection problems last time, loosing two full teams and they are not showing up). For you there is also something strange going on there. Check your latest battles, round 1:



The log probably needs some improvement or did you really always loose against your opponent at 0:00 seconds? Maybe they (swgoh.gg) are still working on fixing the bugs? I would assume so.

At least now they show a message regarding some bugs:

>> Note that Ship Battles and Early Ending Battles are not reporting correct Win/Loss currently.

Anyway, i still don't care about the log. In face i believe this will spice up GAC somewhat with people no longer soley relying on their beloved 0815 (not sure if that expression exists anywhere other than in Germany) setup which isn't super secret at all ;)

So investing a lot of time to get through all previous GACs of your enemy, figuring out their defense and teams and making a new defense setup for your side every single round is fine for you? Good, have fun! But there are others that don't have much time, that play the game for fun and not as a full time job like you or just already invest much more time than they should in other parts of the (mobile!) game - what about those? "Adapt or die"? Oh yeah, that's totally the best way to handle this!

My god what a bunch of snowflake whales on this thread.

"Wraith_Squadron;c-2027001" wrote:
My god what a bunch of snowflake whales on this thread.

Whales, haha