I'm an officer in a guild, and one of our lower powered members set 29 defensive teams with very little thought as to synergy. Leaders with no leader ability, mixed teams that make no sense. If I kick him before battles begin, do his teams remain or will they disappear, allowing us to set more viable defensive teams?

Just kick him out of the guild now for doing that and let us know what happens to his defensive teams. Either way it sounds like you guys are in trouble with and without him.

Even mixed teams or weaker teams can be valuable on defense because your opponents still has to use one of their squads to take them out (which keeps them from using it against your guild stronger teams).

"Grrrr;c-1389528" wrote:Even mixed teams or weaker teams can be valuable on defense because your opponents still has to use one of their squads to take them out (which keeps them from using it against your guild stronger teams). I agree...if he has set 29 squads in defense the opponents have to waste 29 squads to defeat them regardless .imo he done well setting that many for your guild.great effort to him

"RogueSquadronOne;c-1389551" wrote:"Grrrr;c-1389528" wrote:Even mixed teams or weaker teams can be valuable on defense because your opponents still has to use one of their squads to take them out (which keeps them from using it against your guild stronger teams). I agree...if he has set 29 squads in defense the opponents have to waste 29 squads to defeat them regardless .imo he done well setting that many for your guild.great effort to himUnless the guild was otherwise not going to be able to fill all the defense slots, putting in terrible teams is worse than leaving those slots for people who are going to pay attention to what they are doing and put in decent squads.

Kicking someone during "set defense" stage

drojas3870
New Spectator
8 years ago
Just kick him out of the guild now for doing that and let us know what happens to his defensive teams. Either way it sounds like you guys are in trouble with and without him.
Grrrrrrrrrrreer
8 years ago
Even mixed teams or weaker teams can be valuable on defense because your opponents still has to use one of their squads to take them out (which keeps them from using it against your guild stronger teams).
LordDirt
New Traveler
8 years ago
little overreacting there
RogueSquadronOne
New Spectator
8 years ago
"Grrrr;c-1389528" wrote:
Even mixed teams or weaker teams can be valuable on defense because your opponents still has to use one of their squads to take them out (which keeps them from using it against your guild stronger teams).

I agree...if he has set 29 squads in defense the opponents have to waste 29 squads to defeat them regardless .imo he done well setting that many for your guild.great effort to him
LiathSW
8 years ago
"RogueSquadronOne;c-1389551" wrote:
"Grrrr;c-1389528" wrote:
Even mixed teams or weaker teams can be valuable on defense because your opponents still has to use one of their squads to take them out (which keeps them from using it against your guild stronger teams).

I agree...if he has set 29 squads in defense the opponents have to waste 29 squads to defeat them regardless .imo he done well setting that many for your guild.great effort to him

Unless the guild was otherwise not going to be able to fill all the defense slots, putting in terrible teams is worse than leaving those slots for people who are going to pay attention to what they are doing and put in decent squads.
jrs3nrqo
8 years ago
I’m not sure it’s overreacting. He’s certainly decreased our chances of winning in a way that a replacement likely wouldn’t, even if they had a worse roster. Either way, I want to do whatever gives us the best chance to win the current TW. It would be better if his teams required the opponent to use decent teams, but something is better than nothing.
Staubie12
8 years ago
Seems like overkill to kick someone out for that. But I am curious to know what would happen if I had to kick someone out for another reason
anhed0nic
8 years ago
GrandMoff -- his squads will remain where they were deployed, but will be listed as "Mol Eliza"
CCyrilS
8 years ago
I hope you're our opponent :-P
wvuparker
8 years ago
To be safe, stack one or two territories with the most open slots really heavy. (unless you're fighting my guild lol)