"3Cheers4Tyranny;893930" wrote:
"benacrow;893925" wrote:
"3Cheers4Tyranny;893918" wrote:
"benacrow;893915" wrote:
"3Cheers4Tyranny;893902" wrote:
"benacrow;893895" wrote:
"3Cheers4Tyranny;893889" wrote:
"benacrow;893887" wrote:
"3Cheers4Tyranny;893885" wrote:
"benacrow;893875" wrote:
"3Cheers4Tyranny;893864" wrote:
"benacrow;893861" wrote:
"3Cheers4Tyranny;893857" wrote:
Haha, another classic example of someone rewriting my thread, not that I don't appreciate your suggestions and feedback, but it would be better to make your own thread as it would get more atrention.
I'm sorry, but this is what people post about. What do you want people to post? 'OMG ur so clever that's perfect'?
"Darth_Amarth;893852" wrote:
"3Cheers4Tyranny;91835" wrote:
Hello everyone! Today I'm going to give my suggestions about Mace getting reworked. In this post, I'm trying to make him more viable. I hope you enjoy my suggestions:
Invincible Assualt
Deal Physical Damage to target enemy with a 70% chance to inflict speed down and a 50% chance to Daze. If the targeted enemy is a sith, this attack deals twice as much damage and the daze chance is 100% can not be resisted.
Smite
Deal unavoidable physical damage to target enemy and remove all positive status effects. If the targeted enemy was a sith, then Mace will stun.
Vaapad
Jedi allies gain 20% speed, 50% critical chance and 25% critical damage. For every critical hit a Jedi makes, a random enemy will be exposed.
Shatterpoint
Mace gains 7.5% speed and 25% offense for every Sith present and gains Tenacity up for 2 turns and 70% TM everytime a Sith is defeated.
------------
The reason why I changed Mace's Leader ability and Unique is because he's a master of Vaapad which uses the Dark Side user's energy without being consumed by it making Mace extra fast.
I also made him anti-sith as I think we all know a sith meta is sensible through the force and Mace's character would be a perfect sith-counter.
There's also an arguement claiming Mace shouldn't be reworked as he's too easy to gear. I have one thing to say: Palpatine.
I feel that this is a bit OP. I had suggestions of my own:
- Invincible Assault: Deal physical damage to target enemy. If the enemy has Protection, this attack will deal 15% of the damage to that target's Health. If the enemy doesn't have Protection, Mace recovers Health equal to 15% and Protection equal to 10% of the damage dealt.
- Smite: Deal special damage to target enemy and remove all positive status effects on them. This attack deals 20% more damage to Sith.
- Vaapad: Jedi allies gain 25% Offense and 15% Critical Chance. In addition, Jedi allies have a 50% chance to Expose each enemy until the end of their turn. This effect can't be resisted.
- NEW* Shatterpoint: Mace Windu gains 8 Speed for each living Sith enemy and while he is still alive, Sith have -6% Speed. In addition, every time Mace obtains a debuff, he has 75% chance to apply it back to its source.
This seems more reasonable, but the added protection back seems a little much without being a zeta ability. Only zeta'd toons can recover protection so far, so it'd be a bit OP to not require a zeta to do this.
No, I'm just saying that he/she should make their own thread as it would get more attention. Feedback and rewriting is a completely different thing. And as a side note, you can't speak when refusing to take critism.
There'd be no point to have 100 different Mace rework threads with each player's 'unique' spin on it. That's why people comment on their ideas in the same thread, so you can all share ideas. And most people posting aren't looking for attention; they're just making conversation and posting about the thread topic. If you don't want people to comment on your threads about their ideas as well, then don't make threads.
This isn't a "Mace Windu Rework Ideas Megathread" for crying out loud. I'm trying to help by stating the obvious fact that Amarth's ideas would be more appreciated and widely seen as it's far from common to click on this type of thread and see tons of rewrites.
I don't mind people posting feedback on what should be changed but it's stressful when spending awhile making a thread for it to only be thrown away by someone who's ideas are better. And not making threads over this issue is one of the dumbest things I've heard.
@BentWookie @ShaolinPunk @J0K3R please close this thread, it was worth a shot.
Sounds like you're just posting to get attention then, and don't want anyone to post unless they're telling you how good your ideas are?
Not posting for attention at all, I just don't want a thread that is filled with arguments and pointless bickering :)
I'm trying to be constructive here. Why make a post if you don't want others to post on it about how to make it better?
Fine, your wish is granted.
:neutral: :grey_question:
"benacrow;893895" wrote:
"3Cheers4Tyranny;893889" wrote:
"benacrow;893887" wrote:
"3Cheers4Tyranny;893885" wrote:
"benacrow;893875" wrote:
"3Cheers4Tyranny;893864" wrote:
"benacrow;893861" wrote:
"3Cheers4Tyranny;893857" wrote:
Haha, another classic example of someone rewriting my thread, not that I don't appreciate your suggestions and feedback, but it would be better to make your own thread as it would get more atrention.
I'm sorry, but this is what people post about. What do you want people to post? 'OMG ur so clever that's perfect'?
"Darth_Amarth;893852" wrote:
"3Cheers4Tyranny;91835" wrote:
Hello everyone! Today I'm going to give my suggestions about Mace getting reworked. In this post, I'm trying to make him more viable. I hope you enjoy my suggestions:
Invincible Assualt
Deal Physical Damage to target enemy with a 70% chance to inflict speed down and a 50% chance to Daze. If the targeted enemy is a sith, this attack deals twice as much damage and the daze chance is 100% can not be resisted.
Smite
Deal unavoidable physical damage to target enemy and remove all positive status effects. If the targeted enemy was a sith, then Mace will stun.
Vaapad
Jedi allies gain 20% speed, 50% critical chance and 25% critical damage. For every critical hit a Jedi makes, a random enemy will be exposed.
Shatterpoint
Mace gains 7.5% speed and 25% offense for every Sith present and gains Tenacity up for 2 turns and 70% TM everytime a Sith is defeated.
------------
The reason why I changed Mace's Leader ability and Unique is because he's a master of Vaapad which uses the Dark Side user's energy without being consumed by it making Mace extra fast.
I also made him anti-sith as I think we all know a sith meta is sensible through the force and Mace's character would be a perfect sith-counter.
There's also an arguement claiming Mace shouldn't be reworked as he's too easy to gear. I have one thing to say: Palpatine.
I feel that this is a bit OP. I had suggestions of my own:
- Invincible Assault: Deal physical damage to target enemy. If the enemy has Protection, this attack will deal 15% of the damage to that target's Health. If the enemy doesn't have Protection, Mace recovers Health equal to 15% and Protection equal to 10% of the damage dealt.
- Smite: Deal special damage to target enemy and remove all positive status effects on them. This attack deals 20% more damage to Sith.
- Vaapad: Jedi allies gain 25% Offense and 15% Critical Chance. In addition, Jedi allies have a 50% chance to Expose each enemy until the end of their turn. This effect can't be resisted.
- NEW* Shatterpoint: Mace Windu gains 8 Speed for each living Sith enemy and while he is still alive, Sith have -6% Speed. In addition, every time Mace obtains a debuff, he has 75% chance to apply it back to its source.
This seems more reasonable, but the added protection back seems a little much without being a zeta ability. Only zeta'd toons can recover protection so far, so it'd be a bit OP to not require a zeta to do this.
No, I'm just saying that he/she should make their own thread as it would get more attention. Feedback and rewriting is a completely different thing. And as a side note, you can't speak when refusing to take critism.
There'd be no point to have 100 different Mace rework threads with each player's 'unique' spin on it. That's why people comment on their ideas in the same thread, so you can all share ideas. And most people posting aren't looking for attention; they're just making conversation and posting about the thread topic. If you don't want people to comment on your threads about their ideas as well, then don't make threads.
This isn't a "Mace Windu Rework Ideas Megathread" for crying out loud. I'm trying to help by stating the obvious fact that Amarth's ideas would be more appreciated and widely seen as it's far from common to click on this type of thread and see tons of rewrites.
I don't mind people posting feedback on what should be changed but it's stressful when spending awhile making a thread for it to only be thrown away by someone who's ideas are better. And not making threads over this issue is one of the dumbest things I've heard.
@BentWookie @ShaolinPunk @J0K3R please close this thread, it was worth a shot.
Sounds like you're just posting to get attention then, and don't want anyone to post unless they're telling you how good your ideas are?
Not posting for attention at all, I just don't want a thread that is filled with arguments and pointless bickering :)
I'm trying to be constructive here. Why make a post if you don't want others to post on it about how to make it better?
Wish is granted by letting others comment their ideas without making a fuss about it.
Lol my wish isn't for you to not rage at anyone posting a different idea in the thread. I could care less about who/how people comment. I'm trying to uproot the notion of why you think it's bad for others to give feedback that is different from the main post, because this apparently keeps happening.
It's not bad at all, I was just a bit irritated that I spent awhile writing this thread for only it to be rewriten not half an hour later. But I could care less at this point, it's the internet afterall.
You should not take offense to people 'editing' lets say, your post. It doesn't make it any less good. Doesn't matter how much time you spent writing it. One of the hardest things to do as a writer (believe it or not, posting on forums technically does make us all writers in some way), is to be able to take criticism/alteration of your 'work'.
