What's your guild doing? Please share your guild gp. We are 170 gp guild and can't make a decision.

The better question is, does your guild want GET2 or not?

Yeah, the rewards for 5-10 stars on LS Geo are better than Hoth at 45 stars because you have to rack up that GET2 and g12 salvage, both of which are much more plentiful on LS Geo even at low stars. We're 220M+ (I don't remember exactly and things have been crazy lately with the GP-display bug anyway). We don't have a serious hope of increasing our star count through victory in battle - what we earn through deployments is pretty much all we're going to get. That said, if you could sim HSTR or manually play Rancor, which would you do? It's demoralizing if you go in thinking that you're supposed to win any of the actual battles. If you go in thinking it's like a raid sim, just deploy your toons and wait for your rewards to show up in your in-box, then it's fine. We're taking that latter approach: everyone is expected to deploy, but there's no nagging about getting in battle attempts and no penalty if you don't try. Theoretically it might be more fun to play content for lesser rewards, but goodness gracious, at 220M+ no one in our guild would be seriously playing any of the LS Hoth content until at best day 5, and quite a number of us wouldn't have to take it off auto until day 6 special missions. You'll have to decide for yourselves, but we don't see the LS Hoth as enough of a challenge during regular play. A few of us don't have well-developed Rogue 1 teams, so there's a challenge on day6, but even there we don't actually need to finish all the waves on that mission to get 45 stars, so the challenge isn't meaningful - and again, it's only for a few minutes on one day. So we don't see that we're going to get much extra fun in exchange for the rewards we give up by not "playing" LS Geo. With not much fun to be had in either game mode, we're going with the rare rewards - GET2 and g12 salvage - over a bit of interest on day6 that ultimately doesn't even change our star count. If I were in a 170M gp guild, I'd still go LS Geo, but I admit that at that level your combat success on day 6 still matters, so there's at least some meaningful game play to be had. Whether 1-2 days of challenge for your members is worth lesser rewards is really the tradeoff you're considering. (As long as you can deal with the demoralization problem by changing your expectations to mere deployment, similar to simming rancor)

@Tanzos CG really is doing themselves dirty making content people don't want to play.This.

236 million GP - 50/50 split.Some people are saying:• I want get1 for malak• I want get2 for nego• I want the hoth 45 star achievement• LS geo is not fun, nothing to do but deploy• Hoth is boring, I just auto• I want to have fun• I am fine either way. Just happy to have a good group to run TB with.• I haven't done a LS Hoth for around 6 months. I'm cool either way.All the usual arguments for and against.Our choice for TBs really should have been...• LS Hoth vs DS Geo• DS Hoth vs LS Geo

169 million gpGeoDoing hoth will put you hopelessly behind. If you can pull even 1* you should be doing ls geo for the GET2. This isn't what the devs intended but they obviously don't play the same game as the rest of us. If you think lsgeo is demoralizing it will be twice as demoralizing when you are fighting any of the new ship metas without one yourself.

Republic Offensive or Hoth? | EA Forums

43 Replies

oaktree168
5 years ago
@Apoiuygvbhuytfdresdg

Its really a debate on what your guild wants and where other people are in their progression. If alot of the members in your guild already have Malak and have hoarded for GAS, there is really no point in doing the Hoth raids. Those people are more interested in the ships (negotiator and malevolence) in order to get them maxed out. There's really no right or wrong answer to this, its more of an issue of where you are in the game and/or how you have managed your resources. If they hoarded and you spent, its probably best to take a step back. If you are all in the same boat......well, I have no clue why you are doing LS Geo.

For perspective. We are a 225mil guild but have chosen to run 3 LS Hoth to build up our GET. The rewards are basically the same except for the GET1/GET2 and Hoth gives you roughly a 2.5/1 conversion. Our goal is to give everyone a chance to build up now and tackle LS Geo after CG releases whatever upgrade they are going to release (remember DS GEO before G13 and relics?)

Your only other option would be to leave your guild during a LS GEO and find a LS Hoth. You may even be able to find someone willing to swap with you making it a win/win for all involved. Ask your guild if anyone is involved in a shard chat and try to find a swap there.
comninos1999
Rising Newcomer
5 years ago
Thanks !! I will do that
Slothmastee
5 years ago
"NicWester;c-2029540" wrote:

It’s tempting to pout and throw a fit, it probably even feels good. But it’s not helping anyone. You’re cutting off your nose to spite your face.

Lol pout and throw a fit? How about this is a video game and I don’t choose to spend my time playing video games that aren’t fun.

I swear, you people talk about this game like it’s your job...

Forum Discussion

Republic Offensive or Hoth?

43 Replies

About SWGOH General Discussion

Related Posts

Republic Offense hero without a Zeta???

Genosis: Republic Offensive is a Sham

WORLD’S FIRST™: 8* Phase 1 Geonosis: Republic Offensive

No WORLD’S FIRST: Rebel Fighters SHREDDING Geonosis: Republic Offensive!

Old Republic Zetas

Recent Discussions

Baylan event early return

Dr. Aphra Event made me uninstall the game

Only 1 attempt in TB missions

Welcome to 2025!

Unlikely to reach Level 50 Episode Pass as free to play