I have been a big fan of the Phoenix faction in this game. However, I have been disappointed to find that they are not as useful in the higher levels as they were when I was lower. Though it would be awesome if it was ever decided to do reworks on them, I think a simple solution to give a little more fluidity and adaptability to the faction would be to add the Phoenix tag to Ahsoka Tano (Fulcrum). I think this change, coupled with Hera's leader ability, would bring a welcome improvement to the Phx faction, without negatively impacting anyone who currently uses the faction. We know that CG listens when enough of us ask for something, like how they've added a Rogue One tag (thanks CG!). What do you think?

No, it would be game breaking to share her unique

"DatBoifromdown34;c-1518460" wrote:Yeah as Kyno said. Plus they made the specific sprite of ATF for when she "wasn't" part of the Phoenix squad. (I say that because I am unaware she ever officially joined the Phoenix squadIn a dev video interview they commented that at the endSpoiler (Highlight to read)of the last season she did seem to be more of a member or something to that affectof the last season she did seem to be more of a member or something to that affect

"Kyno;c-1518459" wrote:No, it would be game breaking to share her unique Define "game breaking" please? I mean, unless it would create a new meta, I don't see what the big deal is. (And even then...) That's actually the point really: sharing her unique would allow the Phx faction to function in different (better) ways.

"swgohfan29;c-1518472" wrote:If her and kannan are placed on the same team, they would heal from getting a debuff before losing health equal to 20% of the health gained from that debuff. They basically gain "immune to all debuffs with no negative effect"Seems to me that these two uniques wouldn't come together to make a super-effect. On the contrary, Kanan gets a positive effect from the debuff, while Ahsoka gets a negative effect, so they cancel each other out. The end result is essentially just that rebuffs don't stick. Not exactly OP--seems intriguing to me.

"Yerff_Caasi;c-1518476" wrote:"swgohfan29;c-1518472" wrote:If her and kannan are placed on the same team, they would heal from getting a debuff before losing health equal to 20% of the health gained from that debuff. They basically gain "immune to all debuffs with no negative effect"Seems to me that these two uniques wouldn't come together to make a super-effect. On the contrary, Kanan gets a positive effect from the debuff, while Ahsoka gets a negative effect, so they cancel each other out. The end result is essentially just that rebuffs don't stick. Not exactly OP--seems intriguing to me. So basically they become the sith raid

Should Fulcrum have a Phoenix tag?

NyKynoe
7 years ago
No, it would be game breaking to share her unique
NyKynoe
7 years ago
"DatBoifromdown34;c-1518460" wrote:
Yeah as Kyno said. Plus they made the specific sprite of ATF for when she "wasn't" part of the Phoenix squad. (I say that because I am unaware she ever officially joined the Phoenix squad

In a dev video interview they commented that at the end
Spoiler
of the last season she did seem to be more of a member or something to that affect
Yerff_Caasi
7 years ago
"Kyno;c-1518459" wrote:
No, it would be game breaking to share her unique

Define "game breaking" please? I mean, unless it would create a new meta, I don't see what the big deal is. (And even then...) That's actually the point really: sharing her unique would allow the Phx faction to function in different (better) ways.
Yerff_Caasi
7 years ago
"swgohfan29;c-1518472" wrote:
If her and kannan are placed on the same team, they would heal from getting a debuff before losing health equal to 20% of the health gained from that debuff. They basically gain "immune to all debuffs with no negative effect"

Seems to me that these two uniques wouldn't come together to make a super-effect. On the contrary, Kanan gets a positive effect from the debuff, while Ahsoka gets a negative effect, so they cancel each other out. The end result is essentially just that rebuffs don't stick. Not exactly OP--seems intriguing to me.
swgohfan29
7 years ago
"Yerff_Caasi;c-1518476" wrote:
"swgohfan29;c-1518472" wrote:
If her and kannan are placed on the same team, they would heal from getting a debuff before losing health equal to 20% of the health gained from that debuff. They basically gain "immune to all debuffs with no negative effect"

Seems to me that these two uniques wouldn't come together to make a super-effect. On the contrary, Kanan gets a positive effect from the debuff, while Ahsoka gets a negative effect, so they cancel each other out. The end result is essentially just that rebuffs don't stick. Not exactly OP--seems intriguing to me.

So basically they become the sith raid
Yerff_Caasi
7 years ago
Again, and I'm asking honestly here, what does that mean? It wouldn't literally break the game, so I don't understand what you're trying to communicate.
swgohfan29
7 years ago
"Yerff_Caasi;c-1518485" wrote:
lol I guess. :D That's a decent point I suppose.
Of course, anyone who can land 3 debuff or more at a time (Vader, for example) will still trigger the damage in Ahsoka's unique.

Oh and they re immune to DoTs permanently
collingg
7 years ago
They are totally irrelevant after getting thrawn anyways. At least this would make them useable.
BlueRoseBlade
7 years ago
Narratively?

Yes. Fulcrum is a part of Phoenix Squadron, which is much larger than just the crew of the Ghost. Basically everyone under Admiral Sato was Phoenix Squadron, and the Ghost was just one small part.

And the usual snapshot model doesn't work here, like it does for Fulcrum not being Jedi, or Asajj not being Sith. Fulcrum is specifically a title for Phoenix Squadron intelligence. There is no point where Ahsoka is Fulcrum and isn't Phoenix Squadron.

Now, mechanically, that's a whole other argument, and it may take a rework to her, or changing the Phoenix tag to the Specter tag, or just rolling with it because it's not that important.
Yerff_Caasi
7 years ago
It seems like all the "no"s are upset about the idea of her sharing her unique. She could be mildly reworked and/or not share her unique, still added to the faction, and it wouldn't break anything!