Should the "Raids Rewards" be reviewed ?

Yea it's making our guilds literally compete now

Give higher contributors bonus coins. Split the rest.

Its getting out of control , ill never spend even a dime for this game again . like ever.

Raid rewards must change. In addition to the many valid points listed so far, I add the following. I am in a semi-hardcore guild with 80% of the members in the rank mid 70's, with several 6* & 7*, gear 8-9 toons, while 20% are in low 60's rank with equivalent inventories.

Here is the problem, a lower rank player can contribute significantly more guild currency towards unlocking a raud than a much higher rank member, but then get completely hosed on the raid rewards themselves, simply because they can't compete with their own mates when it comes to the raid.

So now you've created even more friction between mates, and disincentived lower ranked guild members from ever contributing more guild energy than bare minimum. Why should they when they don't get any raid benefit?

Please understand that raid rewards need to change.

"Baggodi;346375" wrote:
If the goal of guilds is team building then ranking rewards within the team is divisive and self defeating.

This

I spent several hours of time recruiting great guys to play the game with, setting up discord to communicate, reading as much as possible, making decisions based on the limited intel we were given only to wind up feeling bamboozled.

My squad is level 72 (as of today : ), however I'm in the bottom 15% of people in my guild and I had no idea this was going to be detrimental to me to find quality people to play with. This guild system is setup to always make someone unhappy and want to go off and start their guild with cruddier players. I have guys that I've known online for a long time and want to play as a group with them. They introduced this game to me but you've now made it not make sense for me to play with them. Please change this!!!

Thank you,
21

So many retard developer. F U Sun Fac maker

"DarthMasterShawn;351799" wrote:
So I made a couple little jokes here, no serious.

After others massive posts I will not go into it. I won't fully judge until I see how it plays out.

I'm whaleish. By that I mean I'll drop so much so fast my bank card calls a halt for fear or fraud, yes it happened again tonight upon trying to get a pack after buying my 5th vault in a couple days. Then I'll go through spells where I do a vault only every 7-10 days, maybe even 2 weeks. Depends what is going on, massive farm, massive leveling of characters/promoting, or new level cap.

I'm in a guild where most do not spend as I do nor farm to my extent. That is their choice mine is mine. I feel guilty because they are as devoted as I am, as passionate as I am, just in different situations. It is not fair for me to change how I've played the game and slow my farming(that I've been working on since before guilds) however we are a team and me hogging the top because I spend and such does make me feel some guilt.

My thing is the purpose of the guild is to be a team. Hard to feel like that if we get the win and some rake it in and others do not. Sure the top prizes are great, but for me less sweet knowing my guildmate put their 100% in and did not reap the same rewards I did. All teams have their allstars and their role players and what not. The point is a team of allstars will not always win it. In 1999 the Buffalo Sabres went to the Stanley cup, they had no player in the top 50 in scoring, the only playoff team not to. I believe the top scorer was ranked in the 70's, yet they dominated and lost on a fluke miscall. Many teams teams of heart and soul pull it out over the big shots. So my point is why should the heart and soul members of the guild, who may have a more limited budget, roster, availability to time their strikes(areas of raid) suffer. A dead rancor is a dead rancor and all should reap the rewards equally if they participated.

Now this comes from the person with the highest power ranking and at the highest player level in the guild. We should share it equally for equal participation.

I don't usually like to quote long posts, as they make it difficult to read the thread (especially on a phone), but DMS hit this out of the park. Well said sir.

Eventually the devs won't be able to ignore it, but maybe EA just doesn't care.

"Ayestes;346201" wrote:
Really everyone who participated should get both boxes, and the variance between credits and guild currency rewards can be somewhere around 15% top to bottom. That's all the incentive someone needs for individual contribution in a raid. That and a leaderboard of who dealt the most damage is all the competition I'd want in a cooperative activity like this.

Perfect! If only we could push this through, the Raid would be the best thing this game ever had and will have.