TB Phase Requirements/Rewards Table

I see your frustration but I think it is misplaced. This is a guild event so it makes sense that a guild that doesn't put 100% in won't get 100% rewards.

If I could offer any advice, I run a guild that plays for fun but is a bit less casual than yours, we have rules, we expect daily play "most" of the time and I enforce some rules, these are in place because it helps everyone have fun, if you don't agree either go to a more serious guild or go more casual. At the moment we have been clearing HAAT for a couple of months and should be on for 25 ish stars, Territory Battles actually seems to have brought us together as a group, we are covering each others weaknesses and so far having lots of fun.

Yes, some may leave to go more hardcore, that is fine, our guild isn't that guild and when we try to be we lose the fun. Make this clear to your guild mates, manage expectations and go back to having fun.

P.s. I'm mostly free to play, I drop what I can when I can, you need to manage your own expectations for what reward you are "entitled" to.