Sorry to necro this thread but I was having this problem too. Sim A received the opportunity but I had Sim B bake the cookies since they were the much better cook. Long story short, The Sim that receives the op must also prepare the item, at least in my experience.
About The Sims 3 General Discussion
Connect with fellow Simmers and share your experiences in The Sims 3 official community.6,703 PostsLatest Activity: 6 hours ago