Feedback: Life state secret gameplay

With the recent focus on private information about sims personal life with Secrets (For Rent) and Scandals (Royalty and Legacy) i think is time for us players to get a better gameplay about occults' secret life state.

I really feel like their secrets aren't secretive enough and when they're discovered it doesn't have any consequence, which doens't make sense since the game itself offers ways to discover occults with "Ask if Mermaid" or "Debate the existence of vampires".

Edit:

So i came up with an idea to solve this at a base game level but to also add gameplay to non-occults and not occult-related gameplay too:

• Add a "Secretive" personality trait for base game so occults (and normal sims) can have a deep gameplay about keeping or revealing their secrets. 

Secretive sims tends are afraid of revealing their secrets while talking to unknown people and attending places as they fear of having their secrets being discovered (by cameras, etc.). These sims can also have a special "Confident" sentiment for deep relationships where they trust enough a person to reveal their secrets. 

Secrets:
- Life state: Being a vampire, werewolf, mermaid, spellcaster, fairy or alien
- Career: Being a criminal or secret agent
- Family recipes
- Flaws: Evil, Mean, Klepto, Hates children, Jealous
- Fears

What do you guys (occult players at least) think? Do you have any suggestion on how this could be fixed?