So my current Sim hits it off really well will Mortimer Goth. I decided to try to pursue this romance. Unfortunately, it has been so difficult! They have an almost maxed out friendship yet every time she flirts, he accepts her advancements one or two times and then rejects them if I continue. Because of the difficulty, I have created a back story that she is madly in love with him, and he is with her, but he is unwilling to show is emotions because he does care about Bella.Has any of your Sims had a successful relationship with Mortimer? Tell me your story!

I haven't seen Mortimer in my game at all. Set the mood right if you can. Woo him in like invite him over and watch a romantic movie. Hopefully this helps.

Invite him over for a romantic dinner etc. And then of course The power of voodoo!https://youtu.be/I4gABvUhhkg?t=31s

I saw this, laughed, realised it was serious and laughed some more. Someone should get Don to seduce him.

Eric Lewis is a hard egg to crack too. I like that though, that both these married men love their wives too much to cheat easily. Well, that's how I play it out in my mind anyway!

I had more trouble with Bob than I did Mortimer. (Bella was dead when my sim started going out with him, maybe that's why) No problem with Eric, but his wife was also dead. Eliza was still alive though. I convinced him to leave her and he was devastated for days. She ended up "letting him go" the day they got married, and by letting him go, I mean drowning him in the pool.

Seducing Mortimer Goth (Tips, Tricks, Stories)

16 Replies

xoJessi
Rising Ace
10 years ago
"moseekee;14383568" wrote:
"moniqueh;14372147" wrote:
I saw this, laughed, realised it was serious and laughed some more. Someone should get Don to seduce him.

OTP

Why not haha. Don is one of my favorites and maybe that's the real reason he didn't want him dating Cassandra. lol. Scorn lover?

Don took Morty out for drinks and started out with friendly talk before getting right into it.
He complimented his "style" and morty just loved that lol.

Butttttt nothing went beyond that. He bailed for the night (said goodbye right after).
I think he was more into someone else anyways.

I'lllll try again. lol
pizza_the_hut82
10 years ago
I was able to seduce him once when I attempted the Black Widow challenge. My Sim built up a friendship with him and convinced him to leave his spouse and then ended up marrying him. I don't feel I did anything different from other times seducing a married sim.
Kattermel
6 years ago
I actually managed to seduce him as well very early in the game. My character is a fashion blogger, and complimented him on his style and talked about books and fashion. I also mixed in flirting and eventually within one night I managed to get him to become my character's boyfriend and stay the night. Hopefully nothing bad happens that they break up, after reading about him lol.
horseandpenguin
6 years ago
I've actually focused on Bella more lol ? She was a tough nut to crack too. What I did is had my sim, which had barista skill, make them both cupid drinks. Even without that: if you just click "flirt" and intermix that with a joke without using any other of the bolder romantic actions until the romance bar is really high, it works. It's slower that way, but it's not as risky as, let's say, doing a "confess attraction" and facing the slap ?
keene61
New Spectator
6 years ago
Reading through this thread, it sounds like Sims who have a good relationship with their spouse won't be as inclined to accept romantic interactions from others. Is this something that people have tested?
EA_Joz
EA Staff (Retired)
6 years ago
Hello everyone, please remember that necroposting is against the rules. I've gone ahead and closed the thread.

Please review our Posting Rules & Guidelines here:

https://forums.thesims.com/en_US/categories/forum-rules

~EA_Joz

Forum Discussion

Seducing Mortimer Goth (Tips, Tricks, Stories)

16 Replies

About The Sims 4 General Discussion

Community Highlights

[INFO] Make sure you meet the minimum requirements (PC/Mac)

Recent Discussions

What happened in your game today, by ONE picture?

Sims 4 Adventure Awaits Negative Discussion thread.

Show the pictures of your lovely pets!

What happened in your game today?

Fall 2025 Roadmap