Where has anyone found sharks out in Island Living? I have even tried having a sim (using the needs cheat to keep her out there) all over back floating in shallow to deep waters on different parts of ...
They only show up in deep waters. You need to wait there until one appears. It's pretty unlikely that your sim will die though. Mine had to spend 4 days in a row in the ocean to die by being pulled by the shark. I kept making him happy so he wouldn't die of hunger/low energy while testing this. He got the shark debuff a lot but the shark never tried to pull him within 4 days. Or maybe I was lucky idk.